Hall of Mirrors: Section 6.1: The Special and General Theory

[Note: In the introduction, the author explained the necessity of using quotes in an unorthodox manner. In this section in particular, it is often best to let Einstein ‘speak for himself’, albeit whilst ‘curating’ the narrative, rather than paraphrase what he said].

6.1.1 Special Relativity Theory: Quotes
If one abandons the ordinary kinematics and builds a new kinematics based on the new foundations, one arrives at [different] transformation equations. We are going to show that based on:
1. The principle of relativity
2. The principle of the constancy of the velocity of light
we arrive at transformation equations that allow us to see that Lorentz’s theory is compatible with the principle of relativity. The theory based on these principles we shall call the theory of relativity. (Vol 3, Doc 2)

The theory of relativity requires that systems of equations in physics turn into systems of equations of the same form if one transforms them by means of the Lorentz transformation. (Vol 4, Doc 1) 

It turns out that the principle of constancy of the velocity of light, and the relativity principle, are incompatible with each other only as long as one holds to the postulate of absolute time, ie to the absolute meaning of simultaneity. If one admits the relativity of time, then the two principles turn out to be compatible with each other; proceeding from these two principles, one arrives at the theory designated as the “theory of relativity”. (Vol 4, Doc 21)

The Special Relativity Theory does not differ from the classical mechanics through the assumption of this postulate [relativity], but only through the postulate of the constancy of light-velocity in vacuum which, when combined with the special relativity postulate, gives in a well-known way, the relativity of synchronism as well as the Lorentz transformation, with all the relations between moving rigid bodies and clocks. (Foundation 1916)

The theory [Lorentz] appeared to be unsatisfactory only in one point. It appeared to give preference to one system of coordinates of a particular state of motion (at rest relative to the ether) as against all other systems of co-ordinates in motion with respect to this one. In this point the theory seemed to stand in direct opposition to classical mechanics, in which all inertial systems which are in uniform motion with respect to each other are equally justifiable as systems of co-ordinates. (Brief Outline 1921)

The whole change in the conception of the ether which the special theory of relativity brought about, consisted in taking away from the ether its last mechanical quality, namely, its immobility. The special theory of relativity does not compel us to deny ether. We may assume the existence of an ether; only we must give up ascribing a definite state of motion to it. (Ether and Relativity 1920)

Development of the special theory of relativity consists of two steps, the adaptation of the space-time “metrics” to Maxwell’s electro-dynamics, and an adaptation of the rest of physics to that altered space-time “metrics”. The first of these processes yields the relativity of simultaneity, the influence of motion on measuring-rods and clocks, a modification of kinematics, and in particular a new theorem of addition of velocities. (Brief Outline 1921)

This theory [Special Relativity] originated as the answer to the question: Is the special principle of relativity really contradictory to the field equations of Maxwell for empty space? The answer to this question appeared to be in the affirmative. [But] if those [Galileo transformation] equations are valid with reference to a system of co-ordinates K, and we introduce a new system of co-ordinates K’ in conformity with them, then Maxwell’s field equations are no longer valid in the new co-ordinates (x’, y’, z’, t’). (Brief Outline 1921)

A more searching analysis of the physical significance of space and time rendered it evident that the Galileo transformation, x’ = x – vt & t’ = t, is founded on arbitrary assumptions, and in particular on the assumption that the statement of simultaneity has a meaning which is independent of the state of motion of the system of co-ordinates used. It was shown that the field equations for vacuo satisfy the special principle of relativity, provided we use the [Lorentz equation]: x’ = (x -vt)/√(1 – v²/c²), y’ = y, z’ = z, t’ = (t-vx/c²) / √(1 – v²/c²). (Brief Outline 1921)

In these equations x, y, z represent the co-ordinates measured with measuring-rods which are at rest with reference to the system of co-ordinates, and t represents the time measured with suitably adjusted clocks of identical construction, which are in a state of rest. Now in order that the special principle of relativity may hold, it is necessary that all the equations of physics do not alter their form in the transition from one inertial system to another, when we make use of the Lorentz transformation for the calculation of this change. In the language of mathematics, all systems of equations that express physical laws must be co-variant with respect to the Lorentz transformation. (Brief Outline 1921)

 6.1.2 Special Relativity: Comment
What became known as the Special Theory of Relativity was contained in the first part, the Kinematical Part, of the 1905 paper entitled On the electrodynamics of moving bodies. According to Einstein this hypothesis: is based on the kinematics of the rigid body, since the assertions of any such theory have to do with the relationships between rigid bodies (systems of co-ordinates), clocks, and electromagnetic processes. Insufficient consideration of this circumstance lies at the root of the difficulties which the electrodynamics of moving bodies at present encounters. 

As previously noted, what Einstein referred to as the ordinary kinematics represented reality, whereas the new kinematics based on the new foundations concerned the reality of light-based representations of reality. So, the hypothesis in Part One is not based on the kinematics of the rigid body, but the relativity of observation. This is why one arrives at [different] transformation equations, based on: 1. The principle of relativity, and 2. The principle of the constancy of the velocity of light, both of which, as interpreted by Einstein, are invalid. There is no direct physical relationship between the electrodynamics (or any other such feature) of bodies, rigid or otherwise, and clocks, ie time, systems of co-ordinates, ie space, and whatever sensed that by whatever sensory system in any form of movement. 

Einstein 1905, Part 1, the Kinematical Part

Para 1, Definition of Simultaneity: using a methodology first proposed by Poincaré, explains how to carry out timing ‘properly’. This is invalid. See Section 4.5.

Para 2, On the Relativity of Lengths and Times: is based on the principle of relativity and on the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light… where the time interval is to be taken in the sense of the definition in para 1. The interpretation of both these principles is invalid, as explained in Section 4.4. Para 2 explains how length (space) varies depending on what referencing system is chosen to carry out the measurement. One methodology, in effect, times it. Length does not actually alter with varying references. See Section 4.6.

Para 3, Theory of the Transformation of Co-ordinates and Times from a Stationary System to another System in Uniform Motion of Translation Relatively to the Former: explains the new transformation laws, which inevitably involve √(1 – v²/V²), since the same mathematics is always used. c replaced V for invalid reasons, as explained in Section 4.4. As a function of the mathematics, c cannot exceed v. The new transformation equations were:  t’ = β[t – (v/c²)x], x’ = β(x – vt), y’ = y, z’ = z, or t’ = [(t-(v/c²)x]/√(1 – v²/c²)], x’ = (x -vt)/√(1 – v²/c²), y’ = y, z’ = z, where β = 1/√(1-v²/c²). 

Para 4, Physical Meaning of the Equations Obtained in Respect to Moving Rigid Bodies and Moving Clocks: It follows that the time marked by the clock (viewed in the stationary system) is slow by 1- √(1 – v2/c2) seconds per second, and whereas the y and z dimensions of the sphere (and therefore of every rigid body of no matter what form) do not appear modified by the motion, the x dimension appears shortened in the ratio 1: √(1 – v2/c2).

Para 5, The Composition of Velocities: negates the rule of addition of velocities with a self-fulfilling mathematical proof based on the above.

Conclusion to Part 1: We have now deduced the requisite laws of the theory of kinematics corresponding to our two principles, and we proceed to show their application to electrodynamics.

Having derived a new transformation rule based on the relativity of observation, Einstein then proceeded to apply this to electrodynamics. This involved using the new transformation equations for any so-called ‘moving’ body. If we apply to these equations the transformation developed in para 3, by referring the electromagnetic processes to the system of co-ordinates there introduced, moving with the velocity v, we obtain the equations…And: Now the principle of relativity requires that if the Maxwell-Hertz equations for empty space hold good in system K, they also hold good in system k; that is to say that the vectors of the electric and the magnetic force of the moving system k, which are defined by their ponderomotive effects on electric or magnetic masses respectively, satisfy the following equations…

There are two issues with this:
1 Specific electrodynamic, etc, effects relating to differential movement, are not the equivalent of relativity effects in the receipt of light-based representations of reality.

2 What constitutes ‘movement’, given that everything is moving? On earth the movements are varied, and considerable. It is just that, at least in respect of the underlying motions, they are omnipresent. So, a differentiation between what is ‘at rest’, and what is ‘moving’, needs validation. Only a proper system of referencing, ie one which takes account of the nature of our existentially closed system, can identify actuals, albeit only from within the system. 

Einstein derived the Special Theory of Relativity, with its new transformation equations, by forcing a reconciliation between his invalid interpretations of the principle of relativity and the principle of the constancy of light. That entailed abandoning the rule of addition of velocities, which he achieved with his new conceptualisation of ‘time’. The equations are based on the factor √(1 – v2/V2). That became known as the Lorentz transformation, but is not a necessary characteristic of Lorentz’s hypothesis, just a simple mathematical expression of the generic relationship between two movements.  See Section 3.2.

Einstein’s Special Relativity involved: 
-only uniform rectilinear, and non-rotary, motion
-only fixed shaped bodies
-only light in a vacuum which travelled in straight lines at a constant speed (c)
-no gravitational force (or if there was, then it was of a type that had no effect, ie the equivalent of there being none).

These conditions were what was ‘special’, a hypothetical state with no relationship to reality, not Relativity. This hypothesis was asserted to be an explanation to a supposed issue, ie the discrepancy between expectations and the outcomes of the Michelson experiments. It was proposed as an alternative to Lorentz’s explanation that matter contracted in a particular way when subjected to a force, causing movement which was different to that which normally prevailed, and reformulated several of his ideas, along with those of Poincaré. 

Einstein thought contraction did not occur, and it was explained with his new understanding of time, and space. Whereas, he actually explained it with the inherent relativity in the receipt of light-based representations of reality. Since both of them used the same mathematics to compare circumstances, they both ‘proved’ that their explanation compensated for their supposed effect, ie it was just self-fulfilling. Also, they both had the same outcome, because the same factor, √(1 – v2/V2), was used.

Hints that what was originally presented needed amendment were expressed by Einstein in his reply to a comment by Abraham (1912): The theory presently designated as “the theory of relativity” rests on two principles that are totally independent of one another, namely 1 The principle of relativity (with respect to uniform translation) 2 The principle of the constancy of the velocity of light From these two principles it is possible to develop the theory currently known as “the theory of relativity”.  

It is common knowledge that it is impossible to base a theory of the transformation laws of space and time on the principle of relativity alone. As we know, this is connected with the relativity of the concepts of “simultaneity” and “shape of moving bodies.” To fill this gap, I introduced the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light, which I borrowed from Lorentz’s theory of the stationary luminiferous ether.

But what about the limits of the validity of the two principles?  We have not the slightest reason to doubt the general validity of the principle of relativity. On the other hand, I am of the view that the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light can be maintained only insofar as one restricts oneself to spatio-temporal regions of gravitational potential.  This is where, in my opinion, the limit of the validity of the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light, though not the principle of relativity, and therewith the limit of the validity of our current theory lies. In my opinion, the present theory of relativity will always retain its significance as the simplest theory for the important limiting case of spatio-temporal events in the presence of a constant gravitational potential.

Leaving aside what the actual faults are with this hypothesis, and accepting Einstein’s rationale, per se, there are still a number of issues:

The notion of the limit of the validity. A theory is either valid, or it is not. Gravity was not new knowledge. The Lorentz hypothesis of actual contraction inherently presumed a force, as some such effect was necessary to cause an actual alteration in movement from that which normally prevailed. Whereas, Einstein’s hypothesis did not provide such an opportunity. Apparently, this new, alternative, idea was based on a better understanding of the relativity of the concepts of “simultaneity” and “shape of moving bodies”, coupled with the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light borrowed from Lorentz’s theory. But that has nothing to do with reality.

Einstein asserted that: It is common knowledge that it is impossible to base a theory of the transformation laws of space and time on the principle of relativity alone. This is incorrect, as there is nothing else a transformation equation can be based on, assuming it concerns reality, and not something else. This is why Galileo’s transformation equation t’ = t, x’ = x – vt, y’ = y, z’ = z is correct, as it reflects reality. That is, the equation concerns the relationship of two motions which must occur at the same time, ie t = t’, because a non-existent entity cannot be compared to an existent one. There is then a difference in one of the three spatial dimensions from the original, which is expressed in terms of vt, where that t is a duration, and not at a given time, which is what t and t’ refer to.

The notion that it was ‘common knowledge’ was a false assertion, and incorrect, per se. This is a device Einstein often used, ie an assertion was described as ‘obvious/well known/etc’ and therefore no explanation was required. Or, in reverse, anyone who thought otherwise was put on the defensive, the implication being they ‘should have known better’. 

However, the main point here is that having stated that a theory of the transformation laws cannot be developed on just one of the two principles, a circumstance which was apparently common knowledge, he then proceeded to do just that. 

That is, he declared that the hypothesis, which had become known as Special Relativity, still had validity, albeit ‘limited’. Having admitted that gravity was not accounted for in his alternative explanation (unlike Lorentz), which meant that one of the two principles was apparently rendered obsolete, when gravity was introduced [though this was not the actual reason for the flaw in his interpretation of the principle of the constancy of light]. This is summarised in the somewhat arcane language: the constancy of the velocity of light can be maintained only insofar as one restricts oneself to spatio-temporal regions of gravitational potential and the present theory of relativity will always retain its significance as the simplest theory for the important limiting case of spatio-temporal events in the presence of a constant gravitational potential. 

In other words, the special circumstance in which the concept of Relativity still supposedly had some validity was a hypothetical circumstance that had no relationship with reality. Scientifically, it is not acceptable to pick and choose what conditions are to be considered, from amongst those that must have relevancy, in order to formulate a theory. Otherwise, it is just a self-fulfilling belief of no scientific value. 

His understanding of what could constitute a principle of relativity was invalid, as it was based on a misinterpretation of Galileo’s ship analogy. His understanding of what could constitute a principle of the constancy of light was invalid, as it is only the start speed of light that is always c. Any constant is an actual, ie not a function of a reference. However, when referenced to something that has a movement of its own then the outcome will vary, while the actual remains constant. That reflects the valid rule of addition of velocities.

All this resulted in the false conclusion that when a constant (be it c, or for practical purposes an ‘atmospheric’ constant for light) was calculated with reference to anything in uniform translational motion, it would always be that constant, ie the Galileo misinterpretation, or the invalid concept of inertial frames of reference. This is impossible, unless everything remained in the same spatial relationship (a solid state), in which case the point is meaningless. The mode of uniform translational motion does not preclude variations in velocity, ie speed and divergence. That presumption contradicted the rule of addition of velocities, which was abandoned. The final compensatory error involved the conflation of reality, with observation.

The circularity of the argument was enhanced when Minkowski reformulated Part 1 of the 1905 paper into a construct which became known as space-time. That is, the errors in Part 1 were then inherent in what became a new, but invalid, configuration of physical existence. Relativity is a hypothesis about the relativity of the receipt of light-based representations, as occurs in either ‘special’ or ‘general’ conditions. Relativity is not a characteristic of reality. As such, the ‘special’ version is invalid, because c is used as a universal reference, and instead of an ‘atmospheric’ c, and references which, just because they are in a certain mode of motion, are incorrectly deemed equivalent. 

All this resulted in conclusions such as: 
Observers moving with the moving rod would thus find that the two clocks were not synchronous, while observers in the stationary system would declare the clocks to be synchronous, while observers in the stationary system would declare the clocks to be synchronous. So we see that we cannot attach any absolute signification to the concept of simultaneity, but that two events which, viewed from a system of co-ordinates, are simultaneous, can no longer be looked upon as simultaneous events when envisaged from a system which is in motion relatively to that system. 

Evaluated from K, the time between two strokes is equal to: t = 1/√(1 – v²/c²), longer than one second. A clock traveling with the velocity v, runs slower, judged from a non-comoving system, than the same clock when it does not travel. Generalizing, one can conclude: Every event in a physical system slows down if the system is set into translational motion. But this slowing occurs only from the standpoint of a non-comoving coordinate system.

If a rod possesses the length l’ when measured at rest, then, if it moves with velocity v along its axis, it will possess the smaller length l = l’[√(1 – v²/c²)] for a non-comoving observer, whereas for a comoving observer, it will always, have the length l’. The greater the velocity v of the moving rod, the smaller the length. If v approaches the velocity of light c, then the length of the rod approaches the value zero. For values of v that exceed the velocity of light, our result becomes meaningless.

6.1.3 Special Relativity: The replacement transformation laws were derived as follows:
[S and S’] each possess a group of clocks that run-in synchrony [as determined by Einstein] when the two systems are at relative rest with respect to each other. Thus the velocity of light in a vacuum [used as it is constant and not because it is the speed of observational light] must be expressed by the same number in the two systems. Let t, x, y, z be the coordinates of an elementary event with respect to S, and t’, x’, y’, z’ the coordinates of the same event with respect to S’. We seek to find the relations that link these two groups.

These relations must be linear, because of the homogeneity of time and space, and time t is therefore linked with time t’ by a formula of the form: t’ = At + Bx + Cy + Dz. We will count the time from the instant when the origins of the two systems coincide, ie when: x’ = 0 and x – vt = 0,  y’ = 0 and y = 0,  z’ = 0 and z = 0, are equivalent ie: x, y, z,  x’, y’, z’  are linked in the form: x’ = E(x – vt),  y’ =Fy, z’ = Gz.

[Footnote: it is easy to understand what we mean by the homogeneity of time and space, or why we assumed a priori that the transformation equations must be linear. For if a rate of a clock at rest with respect to S’, is observed from S, this rate does not have to depend on the location of the clock in S’, nor on the value of the time of S’ in the vicinity of the clock. An analogous remark applies to the orientation and length of a bar linked with S’, and observed from S. Only when the transformation equations are linear are these conditions satisfied].

To determine the constants A, B, C, D, E, F, G, we assert that, according to the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light, it has the same value, c, with respect to the two systems, ie the two equations: x² + y² + z² = c²t²  &  x’² + y’² + z’² = c²t’² are equivalent. Replacing in the second of these equations t’, x’, y’, z’ by their values obtained from above [the two equations involving A – G], and equating it with the first of these equations, the transformation equations sought are of the form: t’ = ϕ(v)β[t – (v/c²)x],  x’ = ϕ(v)β(x – vt),  y’ = ϕ(v)y,  z’ = ϕ(v)z where β = 1/√(1-v²/c²), and ϕ(v) is a function of v that is to be determined.

We can find ϕ(v) by introducing a third coordinate system S”, which is equivalent to the first two systems, is moving relatively to S’ with a uniform velocity -v, and is oriented with respect to S’, as S’ is oriented with respect to S. Applying the above set of equations twice, we obtain: t” = ϕ(v)ϕ(-v)t,  x” = ϕ(v)ϕ(-v)x,  y” = ϕ(v)ϕ(-v)y,  z” = ϕ(v)ϕ(-v)z

Since the origins of S and S’ are permanently coincident, the axes have the same orientation, and the systems are equivalent, ϕ(v)ϕ(-v) = 1. Moreover, as the relation between y and y’, (as also that between z and z’), does not depend on the sign of v, we have: ϕ(v) = ϕ(-v). It follows that ϕ(v) = 1, as ϕ(v) = -1 is inappropriate. 

The transformation equations, which we call the Lorentz transformations, are: t’ = β[t – (v/c²)x],  x’ = β(x – vt),  y’ = y,  z’ = z, or t’ = [(t-(v/c²)x]/√(1 – v²/c²)],  x’ = (x -vt)/√(1 – v²/c²),  y’ = y,  z’ = z, where β = 1/√(1-v²/c²)

Consider a body attached to S’. Let x’1, y’1, z’1, and x’2, y’2, z’2, be co-ordinates of two points of the body.  At any instant t of the system S, we have the following relations between these two: x₂– x₁= [(√(1 – v²/c²)(x’2 – x’1)],  y2 – y1 = y’2 – y’1,  z2 – z1 = z’2 – z’1. The kinematic configuration of a body in uniform translational motion with respect to a co-ordinate system depends on the velocity v of the translation. Furthermore, the kinematic configuration differs from the geometric configuration solely by a contraction in the direction of the motion, a contraction which is in the ratio 1:√(1-v²/c²). 

Clock H’ will indicate the end of a period at the times in the form: tn’ = n/P0.  Since we seek the time with respect to S, the first of the transformation equations will have to be written:      t = β[t’ – vx’/c²]. And since clock H’ is at rest at the origin of S’, we must always have x’ = 0, which yields: tn = βtn’ = (β/P0)n. Observed from S, clock H’: P = P0/β = P0√(1-v²/c²) periods in a unit time. In other words, a clock moving uniformly with velocity v with respect to a reference system runs, as observed from this system, 1:√(1-v²/c²) times slower than an identical clock that is at rest with respect to this system. 

Let us consider the equations of motion of a point moving in uniform translation with velocity u’ with respect to S’: x’ = uₓ’t’, y’ = uᵧ’t’, z’ = uz’t’.  If one replaces x’, y’, z’, t’ by their values as functions of x, y, z, t, one obtains x, y, z as functions of t and, hence, the components ux, uy, uz of the velocity u of the point with respect to the system S. In this way it is possible to obtain the formula that expresses the theorem of the addition of velocities in its general form, and one can immediately see that the law is valid only in first approximation. In the special case when the velocity u’ has the same direction as the velocity v of the translation of S’ with respect to S, one easily obtains: u = (v + u’)/(1 + vu’/c²). This equation shows that if one adds two velocities, each smaller than the velocity of light in a vacuum, one always obtains a resultant velocity that is smaller than the velocity of light. If one sets v = c – λ, u’ = c – μ, where λ and μ are positive and smaller than c, one gets: u = c[(2c – λ – μ)/(2c – λ – μ + λμ/c)] <c. When one adds the velocity of light c, and a velocity smaller than c, one always obtains the velocity of light.

Let us now consider the most general co-ordinate transformation compatible with the theory of relativity. This transformation is characterized by the fact that   x’, y’, z’, t’ must be linear functions of x, y, z, t, such that the condition: x’² + y’² + z’² – c²t’² = x² + y² + z² – c²t²  will be satisfied identically. The transformations compatible with Newtonian mechanics can be obtained by setting c = ∞. We arrive at the equations of ordinary kinematics if, instead of the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light, we assume the existence of signals whose propagation does not require any time [ie reality rather than representations of reality]. 

6.1.4 General Relativity
The next step was to ‘generalise’ the conditions within which Relativity supposedly prevailed. The following notions were used by Einstein to support this: 

1 Because it was ‘obvious’.
Without any proper evidence, Einstein asserted that Relativity should be universally applicable. Ironically, this is true, but that is because Relativity is actually a function of the relativity of the receipt of light-based representations, ie an inherent feature of the observation of reality, not reality.

The modification which the theory of space and time has undergone through the special relativity theory is a profound one, but a weightier point remains. According to the special relativity theory, the theorems of geometry are the laws about any possible relative positions of solid bodies at rest, and more generally the theorems which describe the relation between    measurable bodies and clocks. Consider two material points of a solid body at rest; then according to these conceptions there corresponds to these points a wholly definite extent of length, independent of kind, position, orientation and time of the body.

Similarly let us consider two positions of the pointers of a clock which is at rest with reference to a co-ordinate system; to these positions there always corresponds a time-interval of a definite length, independent of time and place. It would be shown that the general relativity theory cannot hold fast to this simple physical significance of space and time.

Let two fluid bodies of equal kind and magnitude swim freely in space at such a great distance from one another, and from all other masses, that only that sort of gravitational forces are to be taken into account which any of these bodies exert upon each other. The distance of the bodies from one another is invariable. The relative motion of the different parts of each body is not to occur. The bodies (S1 and S2) are measured with the help of measuring rods, relatively at rest; it is then found that the surface of S1is a sphere and the surface of the other is an ellipsoid of rotation. Why is this difference between the two bodies? An answer to this question can only then be regarded as satisfactory from the epistemological standpoint, when the thing adduced as the cause is an observable fact of experience.

The weightier point was actually that, in reality, entities can have different movements and shapes, and that is what needed an explanation. These variations do not occur as a function of referencing. If it is assumed that they do, then a compensatory factor is required, ie conflation of reality and representations thereof. He then continued the argument:

The Newtonian mechanics does not give any satisfactory answer. It says: the laws of mechanics hold true for a space R1 relative to which the body S1 is at rest, not however for a space relative to which S2 is at rest. The Galilean space introduced, is a purely imaginary   cause, not an observable thing. Thus Newtonian mechanics does not, in the case treated here, actually fulfil the requirements of causality.

A satisfactory explanation can only be thus given: that the physical system composed of S1 and S2 shows for itself alone no conceivable cause to which the different behaviour of S1 and S2 can be attributed. The cause must thus lie outside the system. We are therefore led to the conception that the general laws of motion which determine specifically the forms of S1 and S2 must be of such a kind that the mechanical behaviour of S1 and S2 must be essentially conditioned by the distant masses, which we had not brought into the system considered. These distant masses, (and their relative motion as regards the bodies under consideration) are then to be looked upon as the seat of the principal observable causes for the different behaviours of the bodies under consideration. 

Among all the conceivable spaces R1 and R’1 etc. moving in any manner relative to one another, there is a priori, no one set which can be regarded as affording greater advantages, against which the objection which was already raised, from the standpoint of the theory of knowledge, cannot be again revived. The laws of physics must be so constituted that they should remain valid for any system of co-ordinates moving in any manner. We thus arrive at an extension of the relativity postulate. (Foundation 1916)

But no person can rest satisfied with this condition of things. He asks: “How does it come that certain reference-bodies (or their states of motion) are given priority over other reference-bodies (or their states of motion)? What is the reason for this preference? I seek in vain for a real something in classical mechanics (or in the special theory of relativity) to which I can attribute the different behaviour of bodies considered with respect to the reference systems K and K’. It can only be got rid of by means of a physics which is conformable to the general principle of relativity, since the equations of such a theory hold for every body of reference, whatever may be its state of motion.(General Relativity 1916)

So that nothing remains for us but to regard all conceivable co-ordinate systems as equally suitable for the description of natural phenomena. This amounts to the following law: That in general, Laws of Nature are expressed by means of equations which are valid for all co-ordinate systems, that is, which are covariant for all possible transformations. This condition of general covariance which takes away the last remnants of physical objectivity from space and time, is a natural requirement. (Foundation 1916)

Having failed to allow for some cause, ie a force, which accounts for alteration in movement and shape, and having conflated reality with observation, Einstein was in a self-inflicted predicament. The above arguments about the need for explanations of differences, and privileged references, are all false since the start point is invalid. This is illustrated by: The laws of physics must be so constituted that they should remain valid for any system of co-ordinates moving in any manner. And: How does it come that certain reference-bodies (or their states of motion) are given priority over other reference-bodies (or their states of motion)? These arguments resulted in the incorrect concept that: Laws of Nature are expressed by means of equations which are valid for all co-ordinate systems, that is, which are covariant for all possible transformations. This is only valid in the context of the receipt of representations of reality, light-based or otherwise, not reality.

2 Because classical theory is inadequate.
Since, according to Einstein, classical theory was inadequate, something else was needed. 

The Newtonian mechanics does not give any satisfactory answer. It says: the laws of mechanics hold true for a space R1 relative to which the body S1 is at rest, not however for a space relative to which S2 is at rest. The Galilean space introduced, is a purely imaginary   cause, not an observable thing. Thus Newtonian mechanics does not, in the case treated here, actually fulfil the requirements of causality. (Foundation 1916)

In the general relativity theory time and space magnitudes cannot be so defined that the difference in spatial co-ordinates can be immediately measured by the unit-measuring rod, and time-like co-ordinate difference with the aid of a normal clock. (Foundation 1916)

The means hitherto at our disposal, for placing our co-ordinate system in the time-space continuum, in a definite way, therefore completely fail and it appears that there is no other way which will enable us to fit the co-ordinate system to the four-dimensional world in such a way, that by it we can expect to get a simple formulation of the Laws of Nature.(Foundation 1916).

As explained previously, Einstein’s depictions of the inadequacies of classical theory are based on his failure to understand that they are referring to what actually occurs, whereas Einstein is referring to the reality of representations of what actually occurred. Whether their specific explanations were correct is irrelevant, since that is a different issue. 

3 Because there was a problem with the special circumstances.
Einstein’s dysfunctional logic led him to deduce that: The cause must thus lie outside the system. We are therefore led to the conception that the general laws of motion which determine specifically the forms of S1 and S2 must be of such a kind that the mechanical behaviour of S1 and S2 must be essentially conditioned by the distant masses, which we had not brought into the system considered. These distant masses, (and their relative motion as regards the bodies under consideration) are then to be looked upon as the seat of the principal observable causes for the different behaviours of the bodies under consideration. 

The fact that he had not taken gravity into account in his special circumstances, and an admission that it could be relevant, was referred to in his response to Abraham (1912). But Relativity had apparently been able to occur in the special circumstances, even though one condition of this was no gravitational effect. 

In the absence of a feature which could be the causal factor for the variations, when considering the ‘real world’, ie general circumstance, Einstein had to alight on gravity. This was ‘justified’ because it was an ‘extrinsic’ factor, and had certain characteristics that supposedly meant it did not invalidate his concept of Relativity. Indeed, Einstein tried to argue that gravitational theory could be derived from Relativity, and conversely, gravitational theory proved Relativity. These assertions are invalid, since Relativity concerns a characteristic in the sensing process of reality. This does not necessarily mean that whatever Einstein subsequently wrote about gravity is faulty.

Some of this thinking is encapsulated in the following (General Relativity 1916): 
In contrast to electric and magnetic fields, the gravitational field exhibits a most remarkable property. Bodies which are moving under the sole influence of a gravitational field receive an acceleration, which does not depend either on the material, or on the physical state, of the body. A piece of lead and a piece of wood fall in exactly the same manner in a gravitational field (in vacuo), when they start off from rest, or with the same initial velocity. 

Let us suppose that we know the space-time “course” for any natural process as regards the manner in which it takes place in the Galileian domain, relative to a Galileian body of reference K. By means of purely theoretical operations (ie simply by calculation) we are then able to find how this known natural process appears, as seen from a reference-body K’, which is accelerated relatively to K. Since a gravitational field exists with respect to this new body of reference K’, our consideration also teaches us how the gravitational field influences the process studied. For example, we learn that a body which is in a state of uniform rectilinear motion with respect to K, is executing an accelerated, and in general curvilinear motion, with respect to K’. This acceleration or curvature corresponds to the influence on the moving body of the gravitational field prevailing relatively to K’.

We obtain a result of fundamental importance when we carry out the consideration for a ray of light. With respect to the Galileian reference-body K, such a ray of light is transmitted rectilinearly with the velocity c. It can be shown that the path of the same ray of light is no longer a straight line when we consider it with reference to K’. From this we conclude, that, in general, rays of light are propagated curvilinearly in gravitational fields.  

According to the general theory of relativity, the law of the constancy of the velocity of light in vacuo, which constitutes one of the two fundamental assumptions in the special theory of relativity, cannot claim any unlimited validity. A curvature of rays of light can only take place when the velocity of propagation of light varies with position. Now we might think that as a consequence of this, the special theory of relativity and with it the whole theory of relativity would be laid in the dust. But in reality this is not the case. We can only conclude that the special theory of relativity cannot claim an unlimited domain of validity; its results hold only so long as we are able to disregard the influences of gravitational fields on light.

If we now refer such a domain to a reference-body K’ possessing any kind of motion, then relative to K’ there exists a gravitational field which is variable with respect to space and time. The character of this field will of course depend on the motion chosen for K’. According to the general theory of relativity, the general law of the gravitational field must be satisfied for all gravitational fields obtainable in this way. 

Another part of the argument is (General Relativity 1916):
Let us refer this domain to a random Gauss coordinate system, or to a “mollusc”, as reference-body K′. With respect to K′ there is a gravitational field G. We learn the behaviour of measuring-rods and clocks, and also of freely-moving material points, with reference to K′ simply by mathematical transformation. We interpret this behaviour as the behaviour of measuring-rods, clocks and material points under the influence of the gravitational field G. We introduce a hypothesis: the influence of the gravitational field on measuring-rods, clocks and freely-moving material points, continues to take place according to the same laws, even in the case where the prevailing gravitational field is not derivable from the Galileian special case, simply by means of a transformation of co-ordinates.

The next step is to investigate the space-time behaviour of the gravitational field G, which was derived from the Galileian special case simply by transformation of the coordinates. This behaviour is formulated in a law, which is always valid, no matter how the reference-body (mollusc) used in the description may be chosen.

This law is not yet the general law of the gravitational field, since the gravitational field under consideration is of a special kind. In order to find out the general law-of-field of gravitation we still require to obtain a generalisation of the law. This can be obtained by taking into consideration the following demands: (a) The required generalisation must likewise satisfy the general postulate of relativity, (b) If there is any matter in the domain under consideration, only its inertial mass, and thus only its energy is of importance for its effect in exciting a field, (c) Gravitational field and matter together must satisfy the law of the conservation of energy (and of impulse).

Finally, the general principle of relativity permits us to determine the influence of the gravitational field on the course of all those processes which take place according to known laws when a gravitational field is absent i.e. which have already been fitted into the frame of the special theory of relativity. In this connection we proceed in principle according to the method which has already been explained for measuring-rods, clocks and freely moving material points. The theory of gravitation derived in this way from the general postulate of relativity excels not only in its beauty; nor in removing the defect attaching to classical mechanics; nor in interpreting the empirical law of the equality of inertial and gravitational mass; but it has also already explained a result of observation in astronomy, against which  classical mechanics is powerless.

If we confine the application of the theory to the case where the gravitational fields can be regarded as being weak, and in which all masses move with respect to the coordinate system with velocities which are small compared with the velocity of light, we then obtain as a first approximation the Newtonian theory. Thus, the latter theory is obtained here without any particular assumption, whereas Newton had to introduce the hypothesis that the force of attraction between mutually attracting material points is inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them. If we increase the accuracy of the calculation, deviations from the theory of Newton make their appearance, practically all of which must nevertheless escape the test of observation owing to their smallness.

An alternative form of argument from Foundation 1916 is:
There is also a well-known physical fact which favours an extension of the relativity theory. Let there be a Galilean co-ordinate system K relative to which, at least in the four-dimensional region considered, a mass at a sufficient distance from other masses moves uniformly in a line. Let K’ be a second co-ordinate system which has a uniformly accelerated motion relative to K. Relative to K’ any mass at a sufficiently great distance experiences an accelerated motion such that its acceleration and its direction of acceleration is independent of its material composition and its physical conditions.

Can any observer, at rest relative to K’ conclude that he is in an actually accelerated reference-system? This is to be answered in the negative; the above-named behaviour of the freely moving masses relative to K’ can be explained in as good a manner in the following way. The reference-system K’ has no acceleration. In the space-time region considered there is a gravitation-field which generates the accelerated motion relative to K’. This conception is feasible, because to us the experience of the existence of a field of force, namely the gravitation field, has shown that it possesses the remarkable property of imparting the same acceleration to all bodies. The mechanical behaviour of the bodies relative to K’ is the same as experience would expect with reference to systems which we assume from habit as stationary; thus it explains why from the physical stand-point it can be assumed that the systems K and K’ can both with the same legitimacy be taken as at rest, that is, they will be equivalent as systems of reference for a description of physical phenomena.

It may be that gravitational waves cause alteration in speed and divergence in direction. But that is not the same as attributing this effect to the affect on a sequence of light-based representations, when conflating reality with representations thereof. Neither can it be assumed that such a detected effect is necessarily a function of a gravitational wave. Varying the reference alters what is perceived, not reality.  Since a gravitational field exists with respect to this new body of reference K’, our consideration also teaches us how the gravitational field influences the process studied. For example, we learn that a body which is in a state of uniform rectilinear motion with respect to K, is executing an accelerated, and in general curvilinear motion, with respect to K’. This acceleration or curvature corresponds to the influence on the moving body of the gravitational field prevailing relatively to K’. 

How something ‘appears’, when compared to any given reference, is not the same as what actually happens. In an, albeit brief, attempt to discern how gravitational waves might actually affect light, the author only found jargon about ‘time slowing down’/’space expanding’/etc. As has been stated previously, any given light is a physically existent entity, per se, and therefore potentially subject to alteration during transmission. Since changes to its velocity as it travels in different mediums are known, the author presumes that the actual effect on light of gravitational waves is now known. That is, while Einstein’s notions of acceleration and curvilinearly are functions of his referencing, they may be, but only coincidentally, what actually occurs.

Another pertinent example of this fallacy is: We see immediately that the principle of the constancy of light-velocity must be modified, for we recognise easily that the path of a ray of light with reference to K’ must be, in general, curved, when light travels with a definite and constant velocity in a straight line with reference to K. Any given occurrence can be compared to any given reference, which will result in different outcomes. The resulting statements are correct, but only given the rules invoked. However, it is a fundamentally pointless exercise, as the requirement is to establish what actually happened, and there is a possibility of reifying concepts, and conflating them with reality, in this approach. 

The character of this field will depend on the motion chosen for K’ only within the constraint of the specified comparison. The effect on whatever is affected by any given gravitational field, at any given time, is the result of the physical relationship between the field and the entity involved. 

Neither can any kind of motion, whatever that actually refers to, just be attributed to gravity. The general law of the gravitational field has no relationship with the general form of relativity, hence, gravitational fields are not obtainable in this way. The observed effects can be used to discern what actually occurred, as they can with anything else. Neither was the intial form of Relativity a function of the law of the constancy of the velocity of light. The velocity of light does not depend on the space-time co-ordinates (ie references), but on what physical effects it encounters during transmission, which could include a specific gravitational force, ie not some hypothetical generality. The presence of a gravitational field does not invalidate the definition of the coordinates and the time, which led us to our objective in the special theory of relativity. Those, as defined by Einstein, were invalid, per se, because they were based on an invalid methodology for timing, and measuring distance.

The following assertions are invalid:
If we now refer such a domain to a reference-body K’ possessing any kind of motion, then relative to K’ there exists a gravitational field which is variable with respect to space and time. The character of this field will of course depend on the motion chosen for K’. According to the general theory of relativity, the general law of the gravitational field must be satisfied for all gravitational fields obtainable in this way. (General Relativity 1916)

We see that the working out of the general relativity theory must, at the same time, lead to a theory of gravitation; for we can “create” a gravitational field by a simple variation of the co-ordinate system. (Foundation 1916)

The pysical relationship implied does not exist. Put simply, Einstein identified a relativity in observation which was conflated with reality. Then, when he had to involve gravity, the effects thereof were seen to be similar. So he deduced an interchangeability, on the basis of an apparent equivalence, between gravitational, and relativity, theory. 

Ultimately, this led to the following (General Relativity 1916):
In the first part we were able to make use of space-time co-ordinates which allowed of a simple and direct physical interpretation, and can be regarded as four-dimensional Cartesian co-ordinates. This was possible on the basis of the law of the constancy of the velocity of light. But the general theory of relativity cannot retain this law. We arrived at the result that according to this latter theory the velocity of light must always depend on the co-ordinates when a gravitational field is present. We found that the presence of a gravitational field invalidates the definition of the coordinates and the time, which led us to our objective in the special theory of relativity.

In view of the results of these considerations we are led to the conviction that, according to the general principle of relativity, the space-time continuum cannot be regarded as a Euclidean one. Here it is impossible to build up a system (reference-body) from rigid bodies and clocks, which shall be of such a nature that measuring-rods and clocks, arranged rigidly with respect to one another, shall indicate position and time directly.

If we desire to adhere to our “old-time” three-dimensional view of things, then we can characterise the development which is being undergone by the fundamental idea of the general theory of relativity as follows: The special theory of relativity has reference to Galileian domains, ie to those in which no gravitational field exists. In this connection a Galileian reference-body serves as body of reference, ie a rigid body the state of motion of which is so chosen that the Galileian law of the uniform rectilinear motion of “isolated” material points holds relatively to it. Certain considerations suggest that we should refer the same Galileian domains to non-Galileian reference-bodies also. A gravitational field of a special kind is then present with respect to these bodies.

In gravitational fields there are no such things as rigid bodies with Euclidean properties; thus the fictitious rigid body of reference is of no avail in the general theory of relativity. The motion of clocks is also influenced by gravitational fields, and in such a way that a physical definition of time which is made directly with the aid of clocks has by no means the same degree of plausibility as in the special theory of relativity. For this reason non-rigid reference-bodies are used, which are as a whole not only moving in any way whatsoever, but which also suffer alterations in form ad lib. during their motion. Clocks, for which the law of motion is of any kind, however irregular, serve for the definition of time. 

Or (Foundation 1916): In the general relativity theory time and space magnitudes cannot be so defined that the difference in spatial co-ordinates can be immediately measured by the unit-measuring rod, and time-like co-ordinate difference with the aid of a normal clock.

Contrary to what Einstein asserts, the space-time continuum, or more precisely physical existence, is a Euclidean one. That is, as explained in Section 2.1.3, any given reality only occurs for as long as there is no alteration in it. The extent to which the co-ordinates, ie the shape, as opposed to the co-ordinates defining spatial position, of any given body alter would need to be proven. In practical terms, it is necessary to assume that any given body retains its shape over a duration of more than one, until there is evidence to the contrary, and particularly not to assume there is some all pervading alteration in shape which is constant and applies to all entity types in all physical conditions. 

That is, what Einstein refers to as our “old-time” three-dimensional view of things/ Galileian domains/ a rigid body the state of motion of which is so chosen that the Galileian law of the uniform rectilinear motion of “isolated” material points holds relatively to it, is reality, and not the reality of light-based representations. Furthermore, according to Einstein a gravitational field of a special kind is then present, if referenced in a certain way: Certain considerations suggest that we should refer the same Galileian domains to non-Galileian reference-bodies also. A gravitational field of a special kind is then present with respect to these bodies. A notion, like any other of this type, which is invalid, as the reality of any given gravitational wave is not a function of its reference.

Summary
Relativity first supposedly existed in a special circumstance involving only uniform rectilinear and non-rotary motion, fixed shaped bodies, light in a vacuum which travelled in straight lines at a constant speed, and no effective gravitational force. With the general circumstance there were gravitational fields, no such things as rigid bodies, the idea of a straight line also loses its meaning, and bodies which possessed any kind of motion. So now: the fictitious rigid body of reference is of no avail in the general theory of relativity. Clocks, for which the law of motion is of any kind, however irregular, serve for the definition of time. The motion of clocks is also influenced by gravitational fields, and in such a way that a physical definition of time which is made directly with the aid of clocks has by no means the same degree of plausibility as in the special theory of relativity. For this reason non-rigid reference-bodies are used, which are as a whole not only moving in any way whatsoever, but which also suffer alterations in form, ad lib, during their motion. 

In other words, all the conditions which prevailed originally, and were asserted to be important, were abandoned. 

6.1.5 The mathematical extension of the transformation equations
On the basis of the above, Einstein evolved the following: 

The theory which is sketched in the following pages forms the most wide-going generalization conceivable of what is at present known as “the theory of Relativity;” this latter theory I differentiate from the former “Special Relativity theory,” and suppose it to be known. The generalization of the Relativity theory has been made much easier through the form given to the special Relativity theory by Minkowski, which mathematician was the first to recognize clearly the formal equivalence of the space like and time-like co-ordinates, and who made use of it in the building up of the theory. The mathematical apparatus useful for the general relativity theory, lay already complete in the “Absolute Differential Calculus”, which were based on the researches of Gauss, Riemann and Christoffel on the non-Euclidean manifold, and which have been shaped into a system by Ricci and Levi-Civita, and already applied to the problems of theoretical physics.

The method of Cartesian coordinates must then be discarded, and replaced by another which does not assume the validity of Euclidean geometry for rigid bodies. According to Gauss…

For the case in which the points of the surface considered form a Euclidean continuum with reference to the measuring-rods, but only in this case, it is possible to draw the u-curves and v-curves and attach numbers to them, we have: ds² = du² + dv². Under these conditions, the u-curves and v-curves are straight lines in the sense of Euclidean geometry, and they are perpendicular to each other. It is clear that Gauss co-ordinates are an association of two sets of numbers with the points of the surface considered, of such a nature that numerical values differing very slightly from each other are associated with neighbouring points “in space”. So far, these considerations hold for a continuum of two dimensions. But the Gaussian method can be applied also to a continuum of three, four or more dimensions.

If, for instance, a continuum of four dimensions be supposed available, we may represent it in the following way. With every point of the continuum, we associate arbitrarily four numbers, x1,x2, x3, x4, which are known as “co-ordinates.” Adjacent points correspond to adjacent values of the coordinates. Only when the continuum is a Euclidean one is it possible to associate the co-ordinates x1,x2, x3, x4, with the points of the continuum so that we have simply ds­² = dx1² + dx2² + dx3² + dx4²   In this case relations hold in the four-dimensional continuum which are analogous to those holding in our three-dimensional measurements.

However, the Gauss treatment for ds² which we have given above is not always possible. It is only possible when sufficiently small regions of the continuum under consideration may be regarded as Euclidean continua. We can sum this up as follows: Gauss invented a method for the mathematical treatment of continua in general, in which “size-relations” (“distances” between neighbouring points) are defined. To every point of a continuum are assigned as many numbers (Gaussian coordinates) as the continuum has dimensions. This is done in such a way, that only one meaning can be attached to the assignment, and that numbers (Gaussian coordinates) which differ by an indefinitely small amount are assigned to adjacent points. The Gaussian coordinate system is a logical generalisation of the Cartesian co-ordinate system. It is also applicable to non-Euclidean continua, but only when, with respect to the defined “size” or “distance,” small parts of the continuum under consideration behave more nearly like a Euclidean system, the smaller the part of the continuum under our notice.

We are now in a position to formulate more exactly the idea of Minkowski. In accordance with the special theory of relativity, certain co-ordinate systems are given preference for the description of the four-dimensional, space-time continuum. We called these “Galileian co-ordinate systems.” For these systems, the four co-ordinates x, y, z, t, which determine an event, or in other words, a point of the four-dimensional continuum, are defined physically in a simple manner. For the transition from one Galileian system to another, which is moving uniformly with reference to the first, the equations of the Lorentz transformation are valid. These last form the basis for the derivation of deductions from the special theory of relativity, and in themselves they are nothing more than the expression of the universal validity of the law of transmission of light for all Galileian systems of reference.

Minkowski found that the Lorentz transformations satisfy the following simple conditions. Let us consider two neighbouring events, the relative position of which in the four-dimensional continuum is given with respect to a Galileian reference-body K, by the space co-ordinate differences, dx, dy, dz, and the time-difference dt. With reference to a second Galileian system we shall suppose that the corresponding differences for these two events are dx’, dy’, dz’, dt’. Then these magnitudes always fulfil the condition: dx² + dy² + dz² – c²dt² = dx’² + dy’² + dz’² –  c²dt’²

The validity of the Lorentz transformation follows from this condition. We can express this as follows: The magnitude ds² = dx² + dy² + dz² – c²dt² which belongs to two adjacent points of the four-dimensional space-time continuum, has the same value for all selected (Galileian) reference-bodies. If we replace x, y, z, √(-1ct), by  x1,
x2, x3, x4
, we also obtain the result that ds­² = dx1² + dx2² + dx3² + dx4²   is independent of the choice of the body of reference. We call the magnitude ds the “distance” apart of the two events or four-dimensional points. Thus, if we choose the imaginary variable √(-1ct) instead of t, we can regard the space-time continuum, in accordance with the special theory of relativity, as a “Euclidean” four-dimensional continuum.

We refer the four-dimensional space-time continuum in an arbitrary manner to Gauss co-ordinates. We assign to every point of the continuum (event) four numbers, x1,x2, x3, x4, (co-ordinates), which have not the least direct physical significance, but only serve the purpose of numbering the points of the continuum in a definite but arbitrary manner. This arrangement does not even need to be of such a kind that we must regard  x1,
x2, x3,
 as “space” co-ordinates and x4, as a “time” co-ordinate.

Let us consider, for instance, a material point with any kind of motion. If this point had only a momentary existence without duration, then it would be described in space-time by a single system of values x1,x2, x3, x4. Thus its permanent existence must be characterised by an infinitely large number of such systems of values, the co-ordinate values of which are so close together as to give continuity; corresponding to the material point, we thus have a (uni-dimensional) line in the four-dimensional continuum. In the same way, any such lines in our continuum correspond to many points in motion. The only statements having regard to these points which can claim a physical existence are in reality the statements about their encounters. In our mathematical treatment, such an encounter is expressed in the fact that the two lines which represent the motions of the points in question have a particular system of co-ordinate values x1,x2, x3, x4, in common.   

When we were describing the motion of a material point relative to a body of reference, we stated nothing more than the encounters of this point with particular points of the reference-body. We can also determine the corresponding values of the time by the observation of encounters of the body with clocks, in conjunction with the observation of the encounter of the hands of clocks with particular points on the dials. It is just the same in the case of space-measurements by means of measuring-rods, as a little consideration will show.

The following statements hold generally: Every physical description resolves itself into a number of statements, each of which refers to the space-time coincidence of two events A and B. In terms of Gaussian co-ordinates, every such statement is expressed by the agreement of their four co-ordinates x1,x2, x3, x4. Thus in reality, the description of the time-space continuum by means of Gauss co-ordinates completely replaces the description with the aid of a body of reference, without suffering from the defects of the latter mode of description; it is not tied down to the Euclidean character of the continuum which has to be represented.

We are now in a position to replace the provisional formulation of the general principle of relativity by an exact formulation. The form [above] used, “All bodies of reference K, K‘, etc, are equivalent for the description of natural phenomena (formulation of the general laws of nature), whatever may be their state of motion,” cannot be maintained, because the use of rigid reference-bodies, in the sense of the method followed in the special theory of relativity, is in general not possible in space-time description. The Gauss co-ordinate system has to take the place of the body of reference. The following statement corresponds to the fundamental idea of the general principle of relativity: “All Gaussian co-ordinate systems are essentially equivalent for the formulation of the general laws of  nature”.

We can state this general principle of relativity in still another form, which renders it yet more clearly intelligible than it is when in the form of the natural extension of the special principle of relativity. According to the special theory of relativity, the equations which express the general laws of nature pass over into equations of the same form when, by making use of the Lorentz transformation, we replace the space-time variables, x, y, z, t, of a Galilean reference body K, by the space-time variables, x’, y’, z’, t’ of a reference body K’. According to the general theory of relativity, on the other hand, by application of arbitrary substitutions of the Gauss variables, x1,x2, x3, x4, the equations must pass over into equations of the same form; for every transformation (not only the Lorentz transformation) corresponds to the transition of one Gauss co-ordinate system into another.

In gravitational fields there are no such things as rigid bodies with Euclidean properties; thus the fictitious rigid body of reference is of no avail in the general theory of relativity. The motion of clocks is also influenced by gravitational fields, and in such a way that a physical definition of time which is made directly with the aid of clocks has by no means the same degree of plausibility as in the special theory of relativity. For this reason non-rigid reference-bodies are used, which are as a whole not only moving in any way whatsoever, but which also suffer alterations in form ad lib. during their motion. Clocks, for which the law of motion is of any kind, however irregular, serve for the definition of time. 

We have to imagine each of these clocks fixed at a point on the non-rigid reference-body. These clocks satisfy only the one condition, that the “readings” which are observed simultaneously on adjacent clocks (in space) differ from each other by an indefinitely small amount. This non-rigid reference-body, which might appropriately be termed a “reference-mollusc”, is in the main equivalent to a Gaussian four-dimensional co-ordinate system chosen arbitrarily. That which gives the “mollusc” a certain comprehensibility as compared with the Gauss co-ordinate system is the (really unjustified) formal retention of the separate existence of the space co-ordinates as opposed to the time co-ordinate. Every point on the mollusc is treated as a space-point, and every material point which is at rest relatively to it as at rest, so long as the mollusc is considered as reference-body. The general principle of relativity requires that all these molluscs can be used as reference-bodies with equal right and equal success in the formulation of the general laws of nature; the laws themselves must be quite independent of the choice of mollusc.

Einstein went from an existent state of only uniform rectilinear, and non-rotary, motion, and no gravitational force which meant there were only fixed shaped bodies, to one of complete ‘fluidity’. As a representation of physical existence this is invalid, because any given reality involves no variation. This supposed alteration in the nature of existence, and time being treated as a fourth dimension, resulted in Einstein’s suggestion that certain mathematical constructs should be used to relate physically existent entities in terms of space and time.  

6.1.6 General Relativity Theory: Progression
The first manifestation of the “general principle of relativity” was: All bodies of reference K, K′, etc, are equivalent for the description of natural phenomena (formulation of the general laws of nature), whatever may be their state of motion.

2 This then became: Laws of Nature are expressed by means of equations which are valid for all co-ordinate systems which are covariant for all possible transformations. 

Since, this condition takes away the last remnants of physical objectivity from space and time. In mathematics, all systems of equations that express physical laws must be co-variant with the Lorentz transformation. But, this cannot be maintained because the use of rigid reference-bodies, in the sense of the method followed in the special theory of relativity, is in general not possible in space-time description. So the Gauss co-ordinate system has to take the place of the body of reference. Therefore, it became:

3 All Gaussian co-ordinate systems are essentially equivalent for the formulation of the general laws of nature. 

Which can be stated in another form which renders it more intelligible than it is when in the form of the natural extension of the special principle of relativity. According to the special theory of relativity, the equations which express the general laws of nature pass over into equations of the same form when, by use of the Lorentz transformation, we replace the space-time variables, x, y, z, t, of a Galilean reference body K, by x’, y’, z’, t’ of a reference body K’. According to the general theory of relativity, on the other hand:

4 By application of arbitrary substitutions of the Gauss variables, x1, x2, x3, x4, the equations must pass over into equations of the same form, for every transformation (not only the Lorentz transformation) corresponds to the transition of one Gauss co-ordinate system into another.

However, in gravitational fields there are no such things as rigid bodies with Euclidean properties; thus the fictitious rigid body of reference is of no avail in the general theory of relativity. The motion of clocks is also influenced by gravitational fields, and in such a way that a physical definition of time which is made directly with the aid of clocks has by no means the same degree of plausibility as in the special theory of relativity. For this reason, non-rigid reference-bodies are used, which are as a whole not only moving in any way, but also suffer alterations in form, ad lib, during their motion. We have to imagine each of these clocks fixed at a point on the non-rigid reference-body. These clocks satisfy only one condition, that the “readings” observed simultaneously on adjacent clocks (in space) differ from each other by an indefinitely small amount.

This non-rigid reference-body, which might be termed a “reference-mollusc”, is equivalent to a Gaussian four-dimensional co-ordinate system. What gives the “mollusc” a certain comprehensibility, compared with the Gauss co-ordinate system, is the, really unjustified, retention of the separate existence of the space co-ordinates as opposed to the time co-ordinate. So:

5 All molluscs can be used as reference-bodies with equal right, and success, in the formulation of the general laws of nature; the laws themselves must be independent of the choice of mollusc. Every point on the mollusc is treated as a space-point, and every material point which is at rest relatively to it is at rest, so long as the mollusc is considered as a reference-body.

Scroll to Top