Hall of Mirrors: Section 4.4: The Argument

4.4.1: Introduction
The principle of constancy of the velocity of light, and the relativity principle, are incompatible with each other only as long as one holds to the postulate of absolute time. It turned out that a sufficiently sharpened conception of time was all that was needed to overcome the difficulty. [Then] proceeding from these two principles one arrives at the theory designated as the “theory of relativity”. 

Every reference-body (co-ordinate system) has its own particular time. Unless we are told the body to which the statement of time refers, there is no meaning in a statement of the time of an event. Before the advent of the theory of relativity it had always been assumed that the statement of time had an absolute significance, i.e. that it is independent of the state of motion of the body of reference.

One had only to realize that an auxiliary quantity introduced by Lorentz and named by him “local time” could be defined as “time” in general. If one adheres to this definition of time, the basic equations of Lorentz’s theory correspond to the principle of relativity, and the [Galilean] transformation equations are replaced by [those].

We call this “The Special Relativity Principle”. By the word special, it is signified that the principle is limited to the case when K′ has uniform translatory motion with reference to K, the equivalence of K and K′ does not extend to non-uniform motion.

The Special Relativity Theory does not differ from classical mechanics through the assumption of this [relativity] postulate, but only through the postulate of the constancy of light-velocity in vacuum which, when combined with the special relativity postulate gives, in a well-known way, the relativity of synchronism, as well as the Lorentz transformation, with all the relations between moving rigid bodies and clocks.

Einstein sometimes started with a comment about the classical approach, in order to distinguish it from his proposed ‘relativistic’ one, which he thought should replace it. The proponents of classism included Newton, Euclid, Descartes, and Galileo. Poincaré thought they invoked a ‘convention’, ie a construct imposed upon reality. Poincaré (1902): There is no absolute space. We only conceive of relative motion; and yet in most cases mechanical facts are enunciated as if there is an absolute space to which they can be referred. There is no absolute time. When we say that two periods are equal, the statement has no meaning, and can only acquire a meaning by a convention. We have not even direct intuition of the simultaneity of two events occurring in two different places. Is not our Euclidean geometry in itself only a kind of convention of language? Thus, absolute space, absolute time, and geometry are not conditions imposed on mechanics.

As explained in Section 2.1 this is invalid. This flawed perspective underpinned the Kinematic Part, Part 1 of Einstein’s 1905 paper, subsequently known as Special Relativity. Einstein incorrectly depicted the theories of Newton, et al, as inadequate since they only involved one particular circumstance, which they did, but it was reality. The issue, for him, being that any such singularity ‘must’ be a ‘privileged’ reference, and hence not allowable, as ‘everything is relative’. While the classicists reflected the invalid ‘everyday’ perspective that physical existence comprises ‘things’ and ‘change’ to them, their modelling imposed a ‘freeze’ on that. So, albeit inadvertently, the classicists depiction was correct. 

Newtonian laws of motion transform to laws of the same form when one passes from one co-ordinate system to another because they reflected reality, as per the closed system, ie not a ‘reality’ with respect to any reference that might be chosen arbitrarily. There is no physical relationship between reality and any such reference. Reality cannot be influenced by whatever it is referred to. Relativity is not an inherent characteristic of physical existence. So, Einstein’s concept cannot be depicting reality, but something else, ie the reality of light-based representations of reality. Einstein not only invoked an invalid referencing system to determine reality, but conflated reality with physically existent representations thereof. His ‘new kinematics’ was actually concerned with observation, not reality.

Einstein’s Special Relativity involved:
-only uniform rectilinear, and non-rotary, motion
-only fixed shaped bodies
-only light in a vacuum which travelled in straight lines at a constant speed (c)
-no gravitational force (or if there was, then it was of a type that had no effect, ie the equivalent of there being none).

That is, it was not the concept of Relativity that was ‘special’, but the circumstances within which it prevailed, which were subsequently abandoned in order to invoke general Relativity.

These quotes sum up the concept of Relativity:
There is no such thing as a “specially favoured” co-ordinate system (ie everything is relative)
Every reference-body (co-ordinate system) has its own particular time. Unless we are told the body to which the statement of time refers, there is no meaning in a statement of the time of an event. Before the advent of the theory of relativity it had always been assumed that the statement of time had an absolute significance, i.e. that it is independent of the state of motion of the body of reference. (ie Relativity of simultaneity)

On the basis of the [Special] theory of relativity the method of interpretation is more satisfactory. Here the contraction of moving bodies follows from the two fundamental principles of the theory; and as the prime factor involved in this contraction we find, not the motion in itself, to which we cannot attach any meaning, but the motion with respect to the body of reference chosen in the particular case in point. (ie Relativity of distance)

The core of Einstein’s reconciliation argument was:
Strictly speaking, however, we have only learned that the following three things are incompatible with one another:
(a) the relativity principle
(b) the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light 
(c) the transformation equations or the law of the parallelogram of velocities or the rule of addition of velocities
One arrives at the theory that is now called “the theory of relativity” by keeping
(a) and (b) but rejecting (c).
So that the theory based on these two principles should not lead to contradictory results, one must renounce the rule of addition of velocities. Well founded as this rule may seem to be at first glance, it conceals no less than two arbitrary hypotheses, which hold sway over all of kinematics.

A subset of this argument reflects the misinterpretation of Galileo. See Section 3.4.2. Whereby, anything moving in the mode of uniform translational motion, irrespective of individual velocity, was deemed to be equivalent as a reference. That led to the false notion of inertial frames of reference. This is exemplified by: The Special Relativity Theory does not differ from classical mechanics through the assumption of this [relativity] postulate. Or: Newtonian laws of motion transform to laws of the same form when one passes from one coordinate system to another one that is in uniform translational motion with respect to the first. This is the property we express when we say that the principle of relativity is satisfied in classical mechanics. Or: In addition to K, all bodies of reference K’ should be given preference in this sense, they should be equivalent to K for the formulation of natural laws, provided that they are in a state of uniform rectilinear and non-rotary motion with respect to K. The validity of the principle of relativity was assumed only for these reference-bodies, but not for others (e.g. those possessing motion of a different kind). In this sense we speak of the special principle of relativity, or special theory of relativity.

When comparing two movements in reality, the time of occurrence for both must be the same, as a non-existent entity cannot have a spatial position, ie t must equal t’. Having misinterpreted Galileo, Einstein then had to resolve the consequence, ie certain references being deemed equivalent when they were not. This prompted a revision of the measurement methodology for time, and hence space, which compensated for the original error, since the same mathematics was involved, ie √(1 – v2/V2). 

More searching analysis of the physical significance of space and time rendered it evident that the Galileo transformation is founded on arbitrary assumptions, in particular the assumption that the statement of simultaneity has a meaning which is independent of the state of motion of the system of co-ordinates used. 

These arbitrary assumptions were, supposedly, in respect of time:
t’ = t. The last of these equations expresses the assumption that temporal determinations have a meaning independent of the state of motion (assumption of “absolute time”).

We have no right to assume, a priori, that the clocks of the two groups can be set in a manner that the two time coordinates of the elementary event would be the same, or in other words, in a way that t would be equal to t’. To assume this would mean to introduce an arbitrary hypothesis which has been introduced into kinematics up to the present time. 

In respect of space these arbitrary assumptions were, supposedly:
What should we understand by the “length of the bar”? One is at first inclined to believe that this concept does not require any special definition. However, we will immediately see that nothing of the sort is true, if we consider the following two methods of determining the length of the bar… All that one can deduct from the principle of relativity is that the two methods lead to the same numerical value for the length only when the bar AB is at rest relative to the system S. But in no way is it possible to assert that the second method yields a value for the length independently of the velocity v of the bar.

Or: If the configuration of a body in uniform translational motion with respect to S, is determined by ordinary geometric methods, by means of measuring rods, or other solid bodies, moving in exactly the same way, the measurements turn out to be independent of the velocity v of the translation: these results give us what we will call the geometric configuration of the body. By contrast, if one marks in the system S the positions of various points of the body at a given instant, and determines the configuration formed by these points by geometric measurements using measuring rods at rest with respect to S, one obtains what we will call the kinematic configuration of the body with respect to S.  The second hypothesis used unconsciously in kinematics is: The kinematic and the geometric configuration are identical. [Whereas] the kinematic configuration of a body in uniform translational motion with respect to a co-ordinate system depends on the velocity v of the translation. [ In Einstein’s language, the geometric configuration is reality, while the kinematic configuration is the reality of light-based representations of reality].

Hence, Einstein’s new alternative presumptions were based on:
For time: Every reference-body (co-ordinate system) has its own particular time. Unless we are told the body to which the statement of time refers, there is no meaning in a statement of the time of an event. Before the advent of the theory of relativity it had always been assumed that the statement of time had an absolute significance, i.e. that it is independent of the state of motion of the body of reference. 

For space: On the basis of the [Special] theory of relativity the method of interpretation is more satisfactory. Here the contraction of moving bodies follows from the two fundamental principles of the theory; and as the prime factor involved in this contraction we find, not the motion in itself, to which we cannot attach any meaning, but the motion with respect to the body of reference chosen in the particular case in point.

Which resulted in:
This shows that one cannot reject, a priori, the possibility that the concept of spatial distance might also possess only a relative meaning. Thus, in addition to the “relativity of time”, we must also admit a “relativity of lengths”. This shatters the foundation on which the original transformation equations for spatial coordinates, and time values, are based. In the theory of relativity, the place of those equations is taken by equations that simultaneously satisfy the principle of relativity and the principle of constancy of the velocity of light. One finds the new equations by formulating mathematically the requirement that every light ray should propagate with the same velocity c in both systems K and K’. In this way one arrives at:        x’ = (x -vt)/√(1 – v²/c²), y’ = y, z’ = z, t’ = (t-(v/c²)x)/√(1 – v²/c²)

This is invalid. While the fact that reality is only manifest via representations of it is a statement of the obvious, it needs to be overtly stated, the consequences determined, and a theory formulated. The differentiation between reality, and the reality of representations of it, must be maintained. Furthermore, the underlying flaws in Einstein’s hypothesis were reified when Minkowski alighted on the supposed implications of the Kinematic Part 1, and developed a new model of physical existence, which is invalid. See Section 5. 

Einstein’s misconceived notion of Relativity led to what might be termed the ‘localisation’ of time, which is why Einstein and Poincaré noted, and then misrepresented, Lorentz’s concept of local time. See Section 3.3. Einstein: It turned out that a sufficiently sharpened conception of time was all that was needed to overcome the difficulty. One had to realize that an auxiliary quantity [by Lorentz], “local time”, could be defined as “time” in general. If one adheres to this definition of time, the basic equations of Lorentz’s theory correspond to the principle of relativity, provided that the [Galilean] transformation equations are replaced. Poincaré: The most ingenious idea [of Lorentz] was that of local time. 

Einstein’s new approach to timing needed a reference. He justified his choice as follows:
The theory of relativity is often criticized for giving, without justification, a central theoretical role to the propagation of light, in that it founds the concept of time upon the law of propagation of light. The situation, however, is somewhat as follows. In order to give physical significance to the concept of time, processes of some kind are required which enable relations to be established between different places. It is immaterial what kind of processes one chooses. It is advantageous, however, for the theory to choose only those processes concerning which we know something certain. This holds for the propagation of light in vacuo in a higher degree than for any other process which could be considered, thanks to the investigations of Maxwell and Lorentz.

Or: For these signals we can use, for example, sound waves that propagate between A and B, through a medium that is at rest with respect to these points. We can use light rays propagating through the vacuum, or through a homogeneous medium at rest with respect to A and B. It does not make any difference whether we choose this or that kind of signals. Still, of all the signals that can be used, we are going to prefer those that make use of light rays propagating in the vacuum, because the synchronization requires that the path out, and the path back, be equivalent, and in our case this equivalence is satisfied, by definition, by virtue of the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light, as light in the vacuum always propagates with the velocity c.

Einstein’s falsehood about timing is encapsulated in: Before the advent of the theory of relativity it had always been assumed that the statement of time had an absolute significance, i.e. that it is independent of the state of motion of the body of reference. A proper timing system does not assume time had an absolute significance, it just invokes a universal reference against which events can be registered. The notion of absolute significance is a function of the nature of reality, which independently occurs at a singular time, and not with respect to an arbitrary reference. In order to measure that, a constant, high frequency, numeric sequence of ‘ticks’ is required as the reference.

It has no relationship with any body of reference, let alone its state of motion. There was no need to give physical significance to the concept of time in the first place, which having done so then required processes of some kind which enable relations to be established between different places. The theory of relativity relied on a relationship which does not exist, resulting in a new methodology for timing which is invalid. 

Einstein’s system of timing, first stated by Poincaré in 1900, involved: 
Einstein: By an elementary event, we understand an event that is concentrated in one point, and is of infinitely short duration. By the time coordinate of an elementary event, we understand the indication, at the instant of the event’s occurrence, of a clock that is situated infinitely close to the point where the event takes place. An elementary event is defined by four coordinates, the time coordinate, and the three spatial coordinates. 

The first hypothesis we wish to discuss concerns the physical notion of time measurement. The meaning of this definition is perfectly clear as long as the clock is sufficiently close to the place at which the event occurs. If the event is taking place in some corner far away from the clock, then it will no longer be possible to establish immediately a correspondence between the different phases of the event, and the different positions of the clock’s hands. If we choose a sufficiently large number of clocks, so that we can ascribe to each of them a sufficiently small domain, we will be able to fix any instant whatsoever, at any location in space, to any degree of accuracy desired. But we cannot obtain in this manner a definition of time useful to a physicist, because we did not say what the position of the clock hands should be at a given instant of time at different spatial points. We forgot to synchronize our clocks. To get a complete physical definition of time, we have to say in what manner all of the clocks have been set at the start. We proceed as follows:…

There is only one way of regulating the clock at B against the clock at A, in such a manner that the signal travelling from A to B would take the same amount of time as the signal travelling from B to A. That is: The reading of the clock at B at the moment the signal AB arrives at B (ie t(b)) minus the reading of the clock at A at the moment the signal AB leaves A (ie t(a)) equals the reading of the clock at A at the moment the signal AB arrives at A (ie t‘(a)) minus the reading of the clock at B at the moment the signal BA leaves B (ie t‘(b)), ie t(b) – t(a) = t’(a) – t’(b). Once the synchronization has been done, the totality of the readings in phase with one another is what we will call the physical time.

Poincaré: Imagine two observers who wish to adjust their timepieces by optical signals. When station B perceives the signal from station A, its clock should not mark the same hour as that of station A at the moment of sending the signal, but this hour augmented by a constant representing the duration of the transmission. Suppose, for example, that station A sends its signal when its clock marks the hour 0, and that station B perceives it when its clock marks the hour t. The clocks are adjusted if the slowness equal to t represents the duration of the transmission, and to verify it, station B sends in its turn a signal when its clock marks 0; then station A should perceive it when its clock marks t. The timepieces are then adjusted. 

They mark the same hour at the same physical instant, but on the one condition, that the two stations are fixed. The watches adjusted in that way will not mark, therefore, the true time; they will mark what may be called the local time, so that one of them will be slow of the other. It matters little, since we have no means of perceiving it. All the phenomena which happen at A, for example, will be late, but all will be equally so, and the observer will not perceive it, since his watch is slow; so, as the principle of relativity requires, he will have no means of knowing whether he is at rest or in absolute motion.

This synchronisation, and hence the timing system based on it, meant that the given time for any given entity became a function of relative spatial position at that time. In other words, instead of t = t’ which represents reality, t = t’ with a delay equal to the transmission time in-built. Whilst invalid anyway as a system, this also required what was involved to maintain their spatial relationship during transmission, otherwise it was useless. Poincaré: but on the one condition, that the two stations are fixed.

This new timing methodology led to the following conclusions:
Evaluated from K, the time between two strokes of the clock is equal to: t = 1/√(1 – v²/c²), and thus longer than one second. A clock traveling with the velocity v, runs slower, judged from a non-comoving system, than the same clock when it does not travel. Generalizing, one can conclude: Every event in a physical system slows down if the system is set into translational motion. But this occurs only from the standpoint of a non-comoving coordinate system.

The kinematic configuration of a body in uniform translational motion with respect to a co-ordinate system depends on the velocity v of the translation. The kinematic configuration differs from the geometric configuration solely by a contraction in the direction of the motion, a contraction which is in the ratio 1:√(1-v²/c²).

Once it is understood that Einstein did not maintain a distinction between reality, and representations of it, then the notions he expressed make sense, but are still invalid: 
We suppose that two similarly made clocks are arranged one at the centre and one at the periphery of the circle, and considered from the stationary system K. According to the well-known results of the special relativity theory it follows, as viewed from K, that the clock placed at the periphery will go slower than the second one which is at rest. The observer at the common origin of co-ordinates who is able to see the clock at the periphery by means of light, will see the clock at the periphery going slower than the clock beside him. Since he cannot allow the velocity of light to depend explicitly upon the time, he will interpret his observation by saying that the clock on the periphery “actually” goes slower than the clock at the origin. He cannot therefore do otherwise than define time in such a way that the rate of going of a clock depends on its position.

Clock H’ will indicate the end of a period at the times in the form: tn’ = n/P0.  Since we seek the time with respect to S, the first of the transformation equations will have to be written: t = β[t’ – vx’/c²]. Since clock H’ is at rest at the origin of S’, we must always have x’ = 0, which yields: tn = βtn’ = (β/P0)n. Observed from S clock H’ indicates: P = P0/β = P0√(1-v²/c²) periods in a unit time. In other words, a clock moving uniformly with velocity v with respect to a reference system runs, as observed from this system, 1:√(1-v²/c²) times slower than an identical clock that is at rest with respect to this system. 

How great is the length of a rod, as observed from the system K, that is at rest with respect to K’, is oriented parallel to the x’ axis, and possesses the length l’ with respect to K’? The x coordinates of the rod ends, satisfy the equation: x₁= (x₁ -vt)/√(1 – v²/c²), x₂’ = (x₂ -vt)/√(1 – v²/c²), so: x2’ – x1’ = (x₂ –x₁)/√(1 – v²/c²) or: l = l’[√(1 – v²/c²)]. This means, if a rod possesses the length l’ when measured at rest, then, if it moves with velocity v along its axis, it will possess the smaller length l = l’[√(1 – v²/c²)] for a non-comoving observer, whereas for a comoving observer, it will always, have the length l’. The greater the velocity v of the moving rod, the smaller the length.

4.4.2 The Principle of Relativity 

1 The same laws of electrodynamics and optics will be valid for all frames of reference for which the equations of mechanics hold good. (Intro 1905)

2 The laws by which the states of physical systems undergo change are not affected, whether these changes of state be referred to the one or the other of two systems of co-ordinates in uniform translational motion. (Section 1 1905)

3 This independence from the state of motion of the system of coordinates used, which we call “the principle of relativity”. (Vol 2 Doc 47)

4 The laws of nature are independent of the translational motion of the reference system, and are identical in all acceleration-free systems. (Vol 3 Doc 17)

5 But this equivalence of the systems K and K’, that are moving uniformly relative to each other, is not limited to mechanics. So far as our experience extends, this equivalence holds generally. The assumption of the equivalence of all such systems K, K’, which rules out the privileging of one state of motion over all others, we will designate as the “relativity principle”. (Vol 4 Doc 21)

6 The principle which was the pivot of all our previous considerations was the special principle of relativity, ie the principle of the physical relativity of all uniform motion. It was at all times clear that every motion must be considered only as a relative motion. If it is simply a question of detecting, or of describing, the motion involved it is immaterial to what reference-body we refer the motion. But that must not be confused with the much more comprehensive statement called “the principle of relativity”. The principle we have made use of not only maintains that we may equally well choose either K or K’ for the description of any event, it also asserts what follows: if we formulate the general laws of nature as they are obtained from experience, by making use of either reference-body, then these general laws of nature (eg the laws of mechanics, or the law of the propagation of light in vacuo) have exactly the same form in both cases. (Special and General Theory 1916)

7 There exists a reference-body K, whose condition of motion is such that the Galileian law holds with respect to it, ie a particle left to itself, and sufficiently far removed from all other particles, moves uniformly in a straight line. All bodies of reference K’ should be exactly equivalent to K for the formulation of natural laws, provided that they are in a state of uniform rectilinear and non-rotary motion with respect to K. All these bodies are Galileian reference-bodies. The validity of the principle of relativity was assumed only for these, but not for others (eg those possessing motion of a different kind). In this sense we speak of the special principle of relativity. (Special and General Theory 1916)

8 The special relativity theory rests on the following postulate which also holds valid for the Galileo-Newtonian mechanics. If a co-ordinate system K be so chosen that when referred to it the physical laws hold in their simplest forms, these laws would be also valid when referred to another system of co-ordinates K′ which is subjected to a uniform translational motion relative to K. We call this postulate “The Special Relativity Principle”. By the word special, it is signified that the principle is limited to the case when K′ has uniform translatory motion with reference to K. The equivalence of K and K′ does not extend to the case of non-uniform motion of K’ relative to K. (Foundation of GR 1916)

9 Now in order that the special principle of relativity may hold, it is necessary that all the equations of physics do not alter their form in the transition from one inertial system to another when we make use of the Lorentz transformation for the calculation of this change. In the language of mathematics, all systems of equations that express physical laws must be co-variant with the Lorentz transformation. (Brief Outline 1921)

As explained in Section 3.4, the principle of relativity as espoused by Einstein, and Poincaré, is invalid. It is based on a misinterpretation of a point made by Galileo. Let us take Galileo’s familiar law of inertia: a material point not acted upon by external forces moves uniformly in a straight line. It is clear that this law cannot hold true if the motion is referred to an arbitrarily moving coordinate system. This is incorrect. The law is a function of reality, not a reference. This need for a reference is driven by Einstein’s underlying belief that ‘everything is relative’. The situation becoming more confused when he conflates reality with representations thereof.

Generally, the issue is that while the movement of any given entity can be described with respect to any other movement, that is somewhat pointless, as its actual movement is only definable with respect to an appropriate reference. This was explained in Section 3.2.2. The ‘laws of nature’, and ‘nature’ itself (eg physical existence), are entirely independent, ie what occurs is not determined by references. There was therefore no need to reformulate Galileo’s fundamental law in the following way: It is possible to choose a coordinate system K, that is in such a state of motion that every freely moving material point moves rectilinearly and uniformly relative to it. Naturally, the law also holds then for all other coordinate systems at rest with respect to K.

This assertion was also incorrect: There exists a whole class of coordinate systems moving uniformly, relative to one another, that are strictly equivalent when it comes to formulating the laws of mechanics. But this equivalence of the systems K and K’ is not limited to mechanics. So far as our experience extends, this equivalence holds generally. The assumption of the equivalence of all such systems K, K’, which rules out the privileging of one state of motion over all others, we will designate as the “relativity principle”.  [It is not clear what generally referred to].

We will state the principle of relativity in the following way: The laws governing natural phenomena are independent of the state of motion of the coordinate system with respect to which the phenomena are observed, provided that this system is not in accelerated motion. This is invalid. It is not true in respect of any motion. The more explicit indication that Relativity actually concerns the relativity of observation, not reality, is noted.

4.4.3 The Principle of the constancy of the velocity of light
To go a step further, we must reconcile the principle of relativity with an essential consequence of Lorentz’s theory, because giving up this consequence would amount to giving up the most fundamental formal properties of the theory. And here is the consequence in question: A ray of light in vacuum always propagates with the same velocity c, which velocity is independent of the motion of the body that emits the ray. In Lorentz’s theory this principle holds only for a system in a special state of motion: In effect, the system must be at rest relative to the ether. (Vol 2, Doc 47).

The most important content of this hypothesis can be expressed as: There exists a reference system (called in Lorentz’s theory “a system at rest relative to the ether”) with respect to which every light ray propagates in a vacuum with the universal velocity c. This ought to hold independently of whether the light-emitting body is in motion or at rest. We designate this proposition the principle of constancy of the velocity of light. (Vol 3, Doc 17).

Hence in accordance with Lorentz’s theory we can proclaim the following, which we call “the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light”: “There exists a coordinate system with respect to which every light ray propagates in vacuum with the velocity c.” This principle contains a far-reaching assertion. It asserts that the propagation velocity of light depends neither on the state of motion of the light source nor on the states of motion of the bodies surrounding the propagation space. The question as to what extent this principle can be considered certain is of fundamental significance for the theory of relativity. For the time being we will content ourselves with the realization that this principle is demanded by Lorentz’s theory. (Vol 4, Doc 1).

The fundamental assertion of Lorentz’s theory, that every light ray in a vacuum always propagates (at least with respect to a certain coordinate system K) with the definite constant velocity c, we will call the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light. (Vol 4, Doc 21)

As explained previously, Lorentz did not reference what Einstein thought was a special state of motion, ie at rest relative to the ether. Neither did his hypothesis involve the existence of a reference system with respect to which every light ray propagates in a vacuum with the universal velocity c. The conclusion Lorentz did come to was that the propagation velocity of light depends neither on the state of motion of the light source nor on the states of motion of the bodies surrounding the propagation space, to quote Einstein. 

Lorentz was referring to the start speed, as the creation of any given light results from the same process, which is why the movement of anything involved had no effect. It is not a speed with respect to any given reference, but a constant (actual) within our existentially closed system. Put another way, it is that speed with respect to any reference, so long as that remains stationary. That is not the same as: There exists a coordinate system with respect to which every light ray propagates in vacuum with the velocity c. That rendition reflects Einstein’s misinterpretation of Galileo, which results in the belief that there is a certain mode of motion in which everything has equivalence, apart from the fact that it cannot be c. 

What must be a ‘real’ light speed has been replaced with a hypothetical one. That is, there is a contradiction between a ray of light in vacuum always propagates with the same velocity c, and which is independent of the motion of the body that emits the ray. These are two different circumstances, ie bodies do not exist in a vacuum. Though in most practical circumstances, the actual transmission speed of any given light, on earth, can be presumed to be constant, but not c, and lights depicting the same occurrence transmit at that speed. 

Apart from the incorrect choice of c as a universal reference, it could neither be c, or an equivalent ‘real’ constant, if the equations were supposed to be applicable to reality, rather than observation. Selecting one overarching reference is incorrect, since whilst any reference must be universal, that is only with respect to the characteristic being considered. Finally, from a practical standpoint, it is impossible to relate any given physically existent state of any given thing, at any given time, to the relevant existent state of a ray of light at that time. 

Einstein justified his choice as follows:
The theory of relativity is often criticized for giving, without justification, a central theoretical role to the propagation of light, in that it founds the concept of time upon the law of propagation of light. The situation, however, is somewhat as follows. In order to give physical significance to the concept of time, processes of some kind are required which enable relations to be established between different places. It is immaterial what kind of processes one chooses. It is advantageous, however, for the theory, to choose only those processes concerning which we know something certain. This holds for the propagation of light in vacuo in a higher degree than for any other process which could be considered, thanks to the investigations of Maxwell and Lorentz.

And: For these signals we can use, for example, sound waves that propagate between A and B, through a medium that is at rest with respect to these points. We can use light rays propagating through the vacuum, or through a homogeneous medium at rest with respect to A and B. It does not make any difference whether we choose this or that kind of signals. Still, of all the signals that can be used, we are going to prefer those that make use of light rays propagating in the vacuum, because the synchronization requires that the path out, and the path back, be equivalent, and in our case this equivalence is satisfied, by definition, by virtue of the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light, as light in the vacuum always propagates with the velocity c.

The conundrum that Einstein had created for himself was that having adopted the belief that ‘everything is relative’, he then needed some reference which was apparently constant, in order to devise transformation equations in what was actually the reality of light-based representations of reality. Moreover, had Einstein properly understood the concept of timing, then he would have known that it was unnecessary to give physical significance to the concept of time, which required processes of some which enable relations to be established between different places. It is immaterial what kind of processes one chooses. It is advantageous, however, for the theory, to choose only those processes concerning which we know something certain. 

Reality occurs at a unique time and spatial position. The issue is to determine what that was on the basis of representations received, which is not limited to those conveyed by light, or humans, or direct experience. Finally, as explained in Section 3.1, the path out, and the path back are not equivalent unless the spatial relationship is fixed, which renders the supposed requirement meaningless, and the system for adjusting timing devices implied here, originally proposed by Poincaré, is an invalid method for synchronising timing devices.

The conundrum is manifest as: If we want to preserve the principle of relativity, we must assume that the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light holds for any arbitrary system not in accelerated motion. At first glance this seems impossible. For let us consider a light ray that propagates with velocity c with respect to the system S, and suppose that we seek to determine the velocity of propagation relative to a system S’, that is in uniform translational motion with respect to the first system. Applying the rule of addition of velocities, we will find a velocity different from c; in other words, the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light that is valid with respect to S is not valid with respect to S’. 

This stems from the misinterpretation of Galileo. Einstein indicated that he had a solution. But, that involved more mistakes with his new conceptualisation of time and space, resulting in his repudiation of the rule addition of velocities. Obviously, if S and S’ have different speeds/directions, then a constant velocity will be different when calibrated with respect to them. That they are in uniform translational motion, per se, is irrelevant. The constant velocity has not changed, but when calculated with respect to a reference that has a movement of its own the outcome must be different.

Since there are two entities there needs to be two rays of light. Therefore, if it is presumed that the two rays are ‘identical’, and not affected differently during transmission, the velocity of those rays with respect to S and S’ will depend on their velocities. That determines any alteration in spatial position with respect to the light source whilst it is travelling. Because, the distance travelled, and the duration thereby incurred, by the light is a function of the spatial position of the occurrence with respect to the position of what became the ‘receiving’ entity when the representation was received. Not the distance between the event and that entity when it happened, or when the representation was received.

While an event occurred at a specific time and place, due to differing spatial positions, when the representation of it was received by various entities will likely vary. This could involve the original differences in spatial position, with respect to the occurrence, not altering during the delay. Or, during that delay there is some alteration in spatial position, either with respect to each other, and/or with respect to what was the position of the occurrence.

The path of a representation, at any given t, would be defined by a distance starting from a point on the path of the ‘emitting’ entity at that t (which is also the start of the distance (x) between the entities at that t), to a point on the path of the ‘receiving’ entity, which would be beyond the end point of distance x. The relationship between ‘distance x’ and ‘distance transmission’, at any given t, is governed by the factor √(1 – v2/V2). With a light-based representation, V would be the actual speed of light in that particular circumstance, ie not c. 

The Doppler effect was explained in the final paragraph of Section 2.1: Assuming a regularity in the sequence, and a constancy of velocity and direction of travel in the ‘emitting’, and ‘receiving’, entities, then the frequency of the sequence, when assessed with respect to what is receiving the representations, will be constant. However, if the relationship of distance, and/or direction, varies from occasion to occasion, then their relative spatial position could vary on each such occasion, and the frequency appear to differ from that emitted to that received. Because, as the spatial relationship alters, successive representations have to travel distances which alter at a varying rate. In this circumstance, a sequence measured with respect to the ‘receiving’ entity, either increases or decreases at a rate dependent upon the rate at which relative spatial position is altering whilst each representation is being transmitted. That is, it appears, with respect to the ‘receiving’ entity, to be speeding up/slowing down, even though the actual emitted rate did not change. 

Einstein then had to resolve this self-inflicted issue, described by his S and S’ example. Why does E=mc²: Cox and Forshaw. Da Capo Press © 2009 addresses the same conundrum:
By page 74, the next step is seen as calculating the ‘distance’ between what are actually existent and non-existent (ie a previously existent) entities. That is, their supposed spatial relationship, given that there is a time difference in their occurrence. The notion of distance continuing over time being a contradiction, by definition, since something cannot be a distance from something else when they do not exist at the same time.  

This is ‘resolved’ by using x = vt. The problems with reifying t and x, and representing x as a duration, have been stated many times in this paper. The authors state: …because they are not of the same type of quantity. We can, however, convert distances into times and vice versa if we use the equation…v = xt…distance and time can be interchanged using something that has the currency of a speed. Let us therefore introduce a calibrating speed; call it c. We can then measure time in metres provided we take any time interval and multiply it by our calibrating speed. At this point in our reasoning c really can be any old speed. 

So, the ‘distance’ in terms of a combination of space and time, known as s, was deemed to be the hypotenuse of an imaginary triangle relating the two entities, with distance and elapsed time representing the other sides. It was either: s2 = (ct)2 + x2, or  s2 = (ct)2  –  x2. 

The argument then invoked to substantiate the choice between them is self-fulfilling. On page 89 it is asserted in relation to an examination of causality that: we have finally managed to interpret the speed c: It is the cosmic speed limit. Nothing can travel faster than c because if it did it could be used to transmit information that could violate the principle of cause and effect. Which is incorrect, because that presumes that the other entity must be a conveyor of a representation, ie as per light, which is not a necessary condition. So, what started as supposedly ‘just any old calibrating speed’ was interpreted, on the basis of its functionality, as a conveyor of representations, and therefore had a speed limit. Also, it was not the actual light which enables sight, but a hypothetical entity in a vacuum. Whether anything can travel faster than light is determined by whether there is an entity in physical existence that can do so. It is not determined by the constraints of a mathematical construct, as per Lorentz 1904. 

Having proved the presumption, the argument continues on page 89 that: No matter how two different observers are moving they must always measure c to be the same. This is incorrect, since by definition, if the observers (entities) are moving at different speeds and directions, albeit in a uniform translational motion, then the speed of light with respect to each observer is likely to be different. As it would be for any entity, ie light does not have some ‘special’ characteristic. This is a function of changes in spatial position occurring during the delay whilst a representation travels. 

These invalid assumptions lead in the next sentence to the conclusion that: The speed c is beginning to look like another special speed we have encountered in this book: the speed of light, but we haven’t proved the connection yet. Their final rejoinder being: Certainly the existence of a universal speed limit offers promise, especially if we can interpret it as the speed of light. The authors then go on to see: if we can obtain the slowing down of moving clocks…an invalid notion arising from the conflation of occurrence and representation. 

The author acknowledges that this was a description of Einstein’s argument, and far more readable and understandable than the original. 

4.4.4 The Reconciliation
On the basis of his flawed interpretations, Einstein then had to reconcile the two principles. This relates to the opening statement in the 1905 paper, when they were asserted to be only apparently irreconcilable.

To go a step further, [from concerns about the ether] we must reconcile the principle of relativity with an essential consequence of Lorentz’s theory. A ray of light in vacuum always propagates with the same velocity c, which velocity is independent of the motion of the body that emits the ray.

In Lorentz’s theory this principle holds only for a system in a special state of motion: In effect, the system must be at rest relative to the ether. If we want to preserve the principle of relativity, we must assume that the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light holds for any arbitrary system not in accelerated motion. 

At first glance this seems impossible. For let us consider a light ray that propagates with velocity c with respect to the system S, and suppose that we seek to determine the velocity of propagation relative to a system S’, that is in uniform translational motion with respect to the first system. Applying the rule of addition of velocities, we will find a velocity different from c; in other words, the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light that is valid with respect to S is not valid with respect to S’. 

So that the theory based on these two principles should not lead to contradictory results, one must renounce the customary rule of addition of velocities. How have we to modify the theorem of the addition of velocities? This question leads to a general one. How are we to find the place and time of an event in relation to S, when we know the place and time of the event with respect to S’? Is there a thinkable answer to this question of such a nature that of light in vacuo does not contradict the principle of relativity? In other words: can we conceive of a relation between place and time of the individual events relative to both reference-bodies, such that every ray of light possesses the velocity of transmission c relative to S and S’? 

Having correctly, albeit coincidentally as it was on the basis of a flawed argument, rendered the ether an irrelevant concern, Einstein then noted a new problem, illustrated by S and S’. His assertion that Lorentz relied on a particular reference was incorrect. However, he was correct in stating that we must assume that the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light holds for any arbitrary system not in accelerated motion, except for the latter caveat, as maintaining the condition of not in accelerated motion, still reflected the misinterpretation of Galileo. The notion that this was needed to preserve the principle of relativity was incorrect.

This outcome, ie that c would vary, was contrary to his usual stance, which was a function of the false equivalence of references in a certain mode of motion. This was written in 1907, Vol2 Doc 47. Normally, S and S’, like K and K’, were, albeit wrongly, considered equivalent. But that might be because it concerned any arbitrary system, so when he applied the rule of the addition of velocities, he revealed the truth, ie the outcome is a velocity different from c. Or, Einstein revealed the difference, as this, in his thinking, proved it was wrong, as the outcome ‘must’ always be c in accordance with his valid, as he saw it, hypothesis, and therefore the rule of the addition of velocities needed amendment. As indicated by at first glance this seems impossible, Einstein thought he had a solution. 

One must renounce the customary rule of addition of velocities. How have we to modify the theorem of the addition of velocities? Since that theorem is self-evidently valid, nobody would consider trying to renounce it. Or put the other way round, whatever argument was used in an attempt to do so, must be invalid. As will be seen in Section 6.2, when Einstein tried to illustrate this with examples, rather than maths, he had to confuse the references.

This led to: How are we to find the place and time of an event in relation to S, when we know the place and time of the event with respect to S’? By definition, the time being considered is the same (t = t’), as the quest is to compare the existence of the two entities, not the existence of one with whatever existed of the other at some other time. An existent entity cannot be compared to a non-existent entity. The latter cannot have a spatial position if it is non-existent at that time. Leaving aside how it was achieved, whatever was done to ‘know the place’ of S’ could have been repeated in order to know the place of S. A more generic answer is that the time and place is derived from the times when the two light-based representations of S & S’, over a sequence of such receipts, were received. Which, when taking into account the known movement of the recipient entity over that duration, reveals what must be the movement, ie sequence of successive spatial positions, of S & S’.

In other words, Einstein asked a false question based on his flawed conception of time and place, which he wrongly considered to be relative instead of independently unique. In order to resolve the predicament, he rephrased the issue: In other words: can we conceive of a relation between place and time of the individual events relative to both reference-bodies, such that every ray of light possesses the velocity of transmission c relative to S and S’? This is not an accurate portrayal of the circumstance, but one that Einstein can address with his invalid concepts. The two events occur at the same time, it is incorrect to conceive of a different time, which then enables the constant to be c when referenced to both S and S’.  

Einstein: we have only learned that the following three things are incompatible:
(a) the relativity principle
(b) the principle of the constancy of the velocity of light 
(c) the transformation equations or the law of the parallelogram of velocities or the rule of addition of velocities
One arrives at the theory that is now called “the theory of relativity” by keeping
(a) and (b) but rejecting (c).

Which is justified by: So that the theory based on these two principles should not lead to contradictory results, one must renounce the rule of addition of velocities. Well founded as this rule may seem to be at first glance, it conceals no less than two arbitrary hypotheses, which hold sway over all of kinematics. 

The first unjustified hypothesis we wish to discuss concerns the physical notion of time measurement… But we have no right to assume, a priori, that the clocks of the two groups [S & S’] can be set in a way that t would be equal to t’. To assume this would mean to introduce an arbitrary hypothesis which has been introduced into kinematics up to the present time. [There is then an argument on how to tell the time ‘properly’] with the conclusion that: A clock moving uniformly with velocity v with respect to a reference system runs, as observed from this system, 1:√(1-v²/c²) times slower than an identical clock that is at rest with respect to this system. See Section 4.5

The second unjustified hypothesis concerns the configuration of a body in motion…What should we understand by the “length of the bar”? One is at first inclined to believe that this concept does not require any special definition. However, we will immediately see that nothing of the sort is true, if we consider the following two methods of determining the length of the bar… The second hypothesis used unconsciously in kinematics can thus be expressed as follows: The kinematic configuration and the geometric configuration are identical. [There is an argument on how to measure a length ‘properly’] with the conclusion that: The kinematic configuration differs from the geometric configuration solely by a contraction in the direction of the motion which is in the ratio 1:√(1-v²/c²). See Section 4.6

One recognizes in this the hypothesis of Lorentz and FitzGerald. This is the hypothesis that looked so strange, and had to be introduced to explain the negative results of the experiment of Michelson. Here this hypothesis appears naturally as an immediate consequence of the principles assumed.

In summary: The rule of addition of velocities, which made one think that Lorentz’s theory cannot be reconciled with the theory of relativity, is based on unacceptable hypotheses which lead to the following transformation equations: t’ = t, x’ = x – vt, y’ = y, z’ = z. The first of these equations, expresses an ill-founded hypothesis about the time coordinates of an elementary event taken with respect to two systems, S and S’, that are in uniform translational motion with respect to each other. The other three equations, express the hypothesis that the kinematic configuration of the system S’, with respect to the system S, is identical with the geometric configuration of the system S’. [For Einstein, the geometric configuration is reality, while the kinematic configuration is the reality of light-based representations of reality].

Another flawed argument to justify the abandonment of the rule of addition of velocities is: It turns out that the result of the Fizeau experiment can be derived quantitatively from (a) and (b). [Because] If we take this standpoint [keeping (a) and (c)], then Fizeau’s experiment forces us to conclude that in a transparent medium, various velocities of light must be possible. For if the velocity of light in the medium, as assessed by an observer moving with the medium, were always equal to Vo, then, according to the rule of addition of velocities, the velocity of light as assessed by an observer not moving with the medium would be Vo + nl, We are thus forced to assume that, in Fizeau’s experiment, the velocity of light relative to the moving medium is, in this medium, different from what it would be in the same medium if the latter were at rest.  

Einstein explored the logic of his hypothesis ad absurdum (Vol 3, Doc 17):
For it turns out that precisely those two seemingly incompatible axioms which were imposed on us by experience, the principle of relativity and the principle of constancy of the velocity of light, lead us to a perfectly definite solution of the space-time transformation problem. 

If we have a solid body that is moving uniformly with respect to the coordinate system k, which we take as the basis for our analysis, then this body appears contracted by a perfectly definite ratio in the direction of its motion, as compared with the shape it has when it is in a state of rest, with respect to this system. If we denote the velocity of motion of the body by v, and the velocity of light by c, then each length measured in the direction of motion, and equal to l in a motionless state, will be diminished because of the body’s motion relative to the non-comoving observer to the length l.√(1 – v2/c2).

If the body has a spherical shape in the state of rest, it will have the shape of a flattened ellipsoid if we move it in a certain direction. When its velocity reaches the velocity of light, it will collapse to a plane. This result loses very much of its oddness, if one considers that this assertion about the shape of a moving body has a complicated meaning, since this shape can be ascertained only with the aid of determinations of time. The feeling that this concept, “the shape of the moving body,” has an immediately obvious meaning is due to the fact that in our day-to-day experience we are accustomed to encountering only such velocities of motion that are practically infinitely small compared with the velocity of light.

And now a second purely kinematic consequence of the theory that strikes us as even more peculiar. We imagine that there is given a clock capable of indicating the time of a reference system k, provided that it is arranged at rest relative to this system. It can be proved that this same clock, when set into uniform motion relative to the reference system k, runs slower, as judged from the system k, in such a way that when the time reading of the clock has increased by 1, the clocks of the system k indicate that, with respect to the system k, there has elapsed the time 1/√(1-v²/c²). Were we to succeed in making the clock move with the velocity of light, the hands of the clock, as judged from k, would move forward infinitely slowly.

The thing is at its funniest when one imagines that the following is being done: One imparts to this clock a very great velocity (almost equal to c), then lets it fly on in uniform motion, and after the clock has covered a long stretch, one imparts to it a momentum in the opposite direction, so that it returns to the point from which it has been launched. It then turns out that the positions of the clock’s hands have hardly changed during the clock’s entire trip, while an identically constituted clock, that remained at rest at the launching point during the entire time, changed the setting of its hands quite substantially. It should be added that whatever holds for this clock, which we introduced as a simple representation of all physical phenomena, holds also for closed physical systems of any other constitution. 

This ‘back to the future’ notion is alone sufficient to indicate the something is wrong with the concept of Relativity, as expressed. That is the purpose of the ad absurdum test.

4.4.5: Conclusion
The two principles, Relativty and Constancy of the velocity of light, as interpreted by Einstein, are interrelated, and both are invalid. Neither can they be reconciled, logically. Einstein’s principle of Relativity deemed that everything in a mode of movement known as uniform translational motion, irrespective of individual velocity, is equivalent as a reference, for calibrating the laws of nature, with anything else which is also in that mode of motion, ie this referencing always results in the same outcome, which is impossible.

Einstein’s principle of the Constancy of light, deemed that everything in uniform translational motion, irrespective of individual velocity, is equivalent as a reference for calibrating a constant. That is, when the constant is referenced to anything in that mode of motion, then the outcome will always be the value of the constant, which is impossible.

Considerations about the relative motion of the conductor and the magnet, etc, in the context of electrodynamics, is not the same as considerations about the relative movement of ‘bodies’ in general. Part 1 proposed a new definition of simultaneity based on a new method of timing, a new definition of measuring length using vt, a new transformation equation for relating ‘stationary’ and ‘moving’ bodies, and a repudiation of the rule of addition of velocities. The concluding sentence of Part 1 was: We have now deduced the requisite laws of the theory of kinematics corresponding to our two principles, and we proceed to show their application to electrodynamics. Whereas, what Einstein actually did was conflate reality with the reality of existent light-based representations thereof, ie observation.

While the subject matter was ostensibly electrodynamics, Part 1 was, in effect, based on a different model of physical existence than what had gone before. That was recognised by Minkowski who formulated a construct which became known as space-time. This meant that Einstein’s ideas became inherent characteristics of a model supposedly depicting our existentially closed system, ie it created a self-fulfilling circumstance.

The only way to reconcile Einstein’s two principles, where reconcile entails doing so within their own rationale instead of on the basis of logic, was: 1) abandon the rule of addition of velocities which rendered Einstein’s interpretation of both principles invalid, even though it is obviously correct, 2) compensate for the effect of that by invoking the hypothesis of Relativity in a circumstance which involves relativity, ie conflate reality with representations thereof. The specific sensory system involved being irrelevant, since in terms of generic physical form, no one sensory system has a precedence, or ‘special’ characteristic. 

The whole argument is circular, based on a sequence of flawed assumptions.

Scroll to Top