Hall of Mirrors: Section 4.1: Introduction
In the Introduction to On the electrodynamics of moving bodies (1905) Einstein proposed two postulates which would suffice for the attainment of a simple and consistent theory of the electrodynamics of moving bodies based on Maxwell’s theory for stationary bodies. The two postulates were:
1 The same laws of electrodynamics and optics will be valid for all frames of reference for which the equations of mechanics hold good. Principle of Relativity.
2 Light is always propagated in empty space with a definite velocity c, which is independent of the state of motion of the emitting body. Principle of constancy of the velocity of light.
Einstein stated that these two postulates were only apparently irreconcilable. But no proper explanation was given in that paper as to why these two principles could be considered irreconcilable in the first place, or why this was not so.
Einstein: The introduction of a “luminiferous ether” will prove to be superfluous inasmuch as the view here to be developed will not require an “absolutely stationary space” provided with special properties, nor assign a velocity-vector to a point of the empty space in which electromagnetic processes take place. The theory to be developed is based, like all electrodynamics, on the kinematics of the rigid body, since the assertions of any such theory have to do with the relationships between rigid bodies (systems of co-ordinates), clocks, and electromagnetic processes. Insufficient consideration of this lies at the root of the difficulties which the electrodynamics of moving bodies at present encounters.
The Lorentz explanation to the perceived issue, for which Einstein proposed this alternative hypothesis, was not concerned with electrodynamics. Neither did it involve the notion that the laws of optics will be valid for all frames of reference for which the equations of mechanics hold good, a reference with respect to the ether, an absolutely stationary space, or assign a velocity-vector to a point of the empty space.
Neither did Lorentz consider anything to be absolutely stationary. For him, stationary was the existent state of equilibrium that normally prevailed, before something temporarily caused an alteration therein. It still involved movement, but that was omnipresent. In respect of the constancy of light, his point was that only the start speed was c, since the interaction always involved the same process. After that, transmission speed depended on conditions.
The conclusion to the Kinematical Part, Part 1, 1905 was: We have now deduced the requisite laws of the theory of kinematics corresponding to our two principles, and we proceed to show their application to electrodynamics.
Einstein then proceeded to apply this to electrodynamics, ie using the new transformation equations on any so-called ‘moving’ body: If we apply to these equations the transformation developed in para 3, by referring the electromagnetic processes to the system of co-ordinates there introduced, moving with the velocity v, we obtain the equations…And: Now the principle of relativity requires that if the Maxwell-Hertz equations for empty space hold good in system K, they also hold good in system k; that is to say that the vectors of the electric and the magnetic force of the moving system k, which are defined by their ponderomotive effects on electric or magnetic masses respectively, satisfy the following equations…
The problem with this is that there is no direct physical relationship between the electrodynamics of bodies (rigid or otherwise), and clocks, ie time, and systems of co-ordinates, ie space. Electrodynamics, and similar effects, are not a function of references.