When Einstein provided examples in General Relativity 1916 to substantiate his ideas, the invalidity of the concept of Relativity is more obvious, as mathematics can obscure flaws.
6.2.1 Section 3: Space and Time in Classical Mechanics. Droppping a stone.
The stone traverses a straight line relative to a system of co-ordinates rigidly attached to the carriage, but relative to a system of co-ordinates rigidly attached to the ground (embankment) it describes a parabola. This is incorrect. Once the stone was let loose it was no longer travelling with the carriage and the person who was holding it. With respect to the pedestrian on the embankment, the stone was seen to drop vertically, while the person who dropped the stone saw it falling in a ‘curve’ as they moved away from the falling stone.
Leaving that aside, the underlying point is what can be deemed to be the ‘actuality’? Einstein: Do the “positions” traversed by the stone lie “in reality” on a straight line, or on a parabola? First, observation, or any form of representation receipt by any type of sensory system, is not reality. Second, as everything is moving, then all movement is relative. The movement of any given entity could be defined by comparing it to any other given entity. But, proper measurement systems use of a reference that has validity, and consistency, in order to ensure comparability of results, and identify actuals.
Given the circumstance that Einstein defines, the best reference is the spatial position occupied by the pedestrian. This is a fixed co-ordinate on the earth, which is not susceptible to variation, and is a practical reference from which to compare outcomes. The point about the spatial position is that it is only deemed to be stationary as a reference, ie it is known to be moving, but it provides a valid, practical, and consistent reference from which to compare all other movements. For now, the additional complication that knowledge is only available through the receipt of representations, in this case light-based representations, can be ignored.
Einstein then asked another fundamental question: Moreover, what is meant here by motion “in space”? Distance is the spatial difference between any pair of entities/representations at any given time. It is a spatial quantity reflecting a unique occurrence in terms of when it happened, and what was involved. For there to be a distance, whatever is under consideration must exist at the same time, since something that is non-existent cannot have a spatial position. Movement is alteration in distance. It is revealed when discrete distances in sequences are compared retrospectively. Since calculating movement, as opposed to distance, involves sequence, any given entity/representation has to be deemed to be the ‘same’ over the duration of the measurement. This comparison enables the calculation of velocity, which is speed, the rate of alteration in distance, and divergence, the rate of alteration in direction.
A distance can only properly be expressed in terms of spatial units with respect to a specific time of occurrence. Alternatively, distance can be expressed in terms of duration, ie x = vt, a hypothetical expression which is defined as the duration that would have been incurred had any given entity, at a known velocity, travelled that distance in either direction. The potential issue with this approach is that t and x can become reified, ie disassociated from reality.
With the aid of this example it is clearly seen that there is no such thing as an independently existing trajectory, but only a trajectory relative to a particular body of reference. What can be clearly seen is that, apart from being invalid, this is a statement of the obvious and of no added value. The assertion that there is no such thing as an independently existing trajectory is invalid. Another implication of this notion is that nothing exists other than what is identified via any sensory system, which is incorrect.
In respect of the idea that a complete description of the motion should have referred to the processes described above: Only one timing device is required, though that is not a necessity, and it is assumed that the process of timing was properly understood. That device should have been provided to the pedestrian, as the purpose of the exercise was to define the path of the fall of the stone with respect to the earth. Describing its path, having allowed for the delay whilst each representation travels especially in a circumstance where spatial position varies, to any passenger, or pedestrian elsewhere, or anything else, is pointless.
However, Einstein then invokes what seemed to be unnecessary conditions: These data must be supplemented by such a definition of time that these time-values can be regarded essentially as magnitudes capable of observation. If we take our stand on the ground of classical mechanics…Einstein proposed providing both those involved receive a timing device. Explanation of the example then stops, with the assertion that there are, apparently, issues: In this connection we have not taken account of the inaccuracy involved by the finiteness of the velocity of propagation of light. With this, and with a second difficulty prevailing here, we shall have to deal in detail later. That is Sections 8, 9 & 10, but no direct reference is made therein as to how this particular example was supposedly resolvable.
6.2.2 Section 5: The Principle of Relativity in the Restricted Sense. The raven.
Let us return to our example of the railway carriage supposed to be travelling uniformly. We call its motion a uniform translation (“uniform” because it is of constant velocity and direction, “translation” because although the carriage changes its position relative to the embankment yet it does not rotate in so doing). Let us imagine a raven flying through the air in such a manner that its motion, as observed from the embankment, is uniform and in a straight line. If we were to observe the flying raven from the moving railway carriage. we should find that the motion of the raven would be one of different velocity and direction, but that it would still be uniform and in a straight line.
Again, the issue is not that any given alternative perspective must be of a certain type of motion which is then the same as the original. The point is to understand the dynamics of any given perspective, and thereby deduce what ‘actually’ happened using a proper process. Assuming a constancy in the speed of travel of the representation, which would otherwise just be an unnecessary additional complexity. If the entity and observer are both in an identical uniform motion, then the sequence of actuality will be the same as the sequence of representation receipt. If the entity has a different speed and/or direction, then the sequence of representation receipt will vary at a constant rate, and what happened could be discerned.
To put it simply, given that the same principle applies, then the observer could be on a fairground carousel, the calculations would just become much more complex. Another way of illustrating the point is to assume that the raven croaks at a regular frequency. The same process would be applied in order to discern the raven’s flight path, it would just involve a different form of sensory system. Varying perceptions do not alter reality, not least because it has already occurred. Perceptions, whether sight based or whatever, are not reality.
Although this Section is concerned with addressing the examples Einstein gave in his 1916 paper, it is worth digressing in order to emphasise, again, an underlying issue. Einstein follows his comment about the raven as follows: Expressed in an abstract manner we may say: If a mass m is moving uniformly in a straight line with respect to a co-ordinate system K, then it will also be moving uniformly and in a straight line relative to a second co-ordinate system K′, provided that the latter is executing a uniform translatory motion with respect to K. It follows that: if K is a Galileian co-ordinate system, then every other co-ordinate system K′ is a Galileian one when, in relation to K, it is in a condition of uniform motion of translation. Relative to K′ the mechanical laws of Galilei-Newton hold good exactly as they do with respect to K.
We advance a step farther in our generalisation when we express the tenet thus: If, relative to K, K’ is a uniformly moving co-ordinate system devoid of rotation, then natural phenomena run their course with respect to K’ according to exactly the same general laws as with respect to K. This statement is called the principle of relativity (in the restricted sense).
If the principle of relativity does not hold, then the Galileian co-ordinate systems K, K′, K″, etc, which are moving uniformly relative to each other, will not be equivalent for the description of natural phenomena. We should be constrained to believe that natural laws are capable of being formulated in a particularly simple manner, and only on condition that, from amongst all possible Galileian co-ordinate systems, we should have chosen one (K₀) particular state of motion as our body of reference. We should then be justified in calling this system “absolutely at rest,” and all other Galileian systems K “in motion.”
If the principle of relativity were not valid, we should expect that the direction of motion of the earth would enter into the laws of nature, and also that physical systems in their behaviour would be dependent on the orientation in space with respect to the earth. Owing to the alteration in direction of the velocity of revolution of the earth in the course of a year, the earth cannot be at rest relative to the hypothetical system K0 throughout the whole year.
The key sentences are;
1 Relative to K′ the mechanical laws of Galilei-Newton hold good exactly as they do with respect to K. [Or the next sentence which is fundamentally a repeat: If, relative to K, K’ is a uniformly moving co-ordinate system devoid of rotation, then natural phenomena run their course with respect to K’ according to exactly the same general laws as with respect to K. This statement is called the principle of relativity (in the restricted sense)].
2 If the principle of relativity does not hold, then the Galileian co-ordinate systems K, K′, K″, etc, will not be equivalent for the description of natural phenomena. We should be constrained to believe that natural laws are capable of being formulated in a particularly simple manner.
3 and on condition that, from amongst all possible Galileian co-ordinate systems, we should have chosen one particular state of motion as our body of reference. We should then be justified in calling this system “absolutely at rest,” and all other Galileian systems K “in motion.”
4 If the principle of relativity were not valid, we should expect that the direction of motion of the earth would enter into the laws of nature. For owing to the alteration in direction of the velocity of revolution of the earth in the course of a year, the earth cannot be at rest relative to the hypothetical system K0 throughout the whole year.
This encapsulates why the concept of Relativity is invalid. Einstein’s numerous allusions to Galileo stems from his misinterpretation of him. He understood it to mean that if in a certain mode of motion, then mechanical laws/general laws/laws of nature, or any other descriptor Einstein chose to use, are the same with respect to any entity involved in such a motion, irrespective of their velocity, in the context of representation receipt. This is incorrect. Neither was it the point Galileo was illustrating, as explained in Section 3.4.
The corollary being that in a different mode of motion this is no longer so, hence his allusion to particularly simple manner. This is true. Except that what is true is that the original idea was incorrect, and therefore the corollary of Einstein’s idea is incorrect. Whereas, from Einstein’s flawed perspective, that was asserted to be true (see last paragraph below).
In that circumstance, he argued that this would necessitate choosing one particular state of motion as our reference. That was true. Although, Einstein often pointed out that a privileged set of coordinates/body of reference is unacceptable, ie this statement was a negative as far as Einstein was concerned. And that it needed to be from amongst all possible Galileian co-ordinate systems, which it did not, as it could be anything.
This, according to Einstein, then meant that the chosen reference could be deemed to be absolutely at rest. The correctness of that depended on what he meant by ‘absolute’. Given his comments made elsewhere, and adoption of Poincaré’s declarations, ie There is no absolute space. There is no absolute time. Not only have we no direct intuition of the equality of two periods, but we have not even direct intuition of the simultaneity of two events occurring in two different places, it can be assumed Einstein was referring to some state which is extrinsic to our existentially closed system, rather than the ‘actuality’. Finally, other than the reference, he asserted all other Galileian systems “in motion.”. Whereas, everything is in motion, including the reference. Which, by definition, as the reference it is deemed to be ‘stationary’in so far as all other motion is referred to it, not that it is ‘actually’ stationary.
His last point concerns what Galileo’s ship analogy was intended to prove. That is, the old idea that earth is stationary was incorrect, but because its movement is omnipresent for everything ‘of’ the earth, the effect of its movement was not necessarily always apparent. Since K0 is of the earth, then it is always at rest relative to the earth, contrary to what Einstein thought. In summary, this demonstrates that Einstein had a flawed understanding of how measuring systems operate properly, conflated representation of reality with reality, and had no understanding of the fundamental nature of our physical existence.
6.2.3 Section 6: The Theorem of the Addition of Velocities Employed in Classical Mechanics. Man walking in moving carriage.
The actuality must be that that the man was walking at a speed of v + w with respect to the embankment (ie earth). However, according to Einstein this may not be true: We shall see later that this result, which expresses the theorem of the addition of velocities employed in classical mechanics, cannot be maintained. Again, later refers to Sections 8, 9 and 10, though this time a reference was at least made to this example. But it involved the two strikes of lightening example, where light from two separate events moved in opposite drections. That is, not only was the lightening example invalid, but it was not comparable anyway with the walking man on the carriage, or the dropping stone, or the raven, examples, and thus what was referred to did not provide an justification for Einstein’s assertions.
Einstein stated the following about the man walking example in Section 9: We were led to that conflict by the considerations of Section 6, which are now no longer tenable. In that section we concluded that the man in the carriage, who traverses the distance w per second relative to the carriage, traverses the same distance also with respect to the embankment in each second. But, according to the foregoing considerations, [in Section 9 with man observing lightening strikes from the train] the time required by a particular occurrence with respect to the carriage must not be considered equal to the duration of the same occurrence as judged from the embankment (as reference-body).
Einstein Section 10: This circumstance leads us to a second objection which must be raised against the apparently obvious consideration of Section 6. Namely, if the man in the carriage covers the distance w in a unit of time, measured from the train, then this distance, as measured from the embankment is not necessarily also equal to w.
That is, no real explanation was provided, just a reaffirmation of the original assertion. In the example Einstein stated: the railway carriage to be travelling along the rails with a constant velocity v, and that a man traverses the length of the carriage in the direction of travel with a velocity w. But, apparently this was not so anymore. Indeed, in another example Einstein thought he was able to conclude that the same train was of different lengths (Section 10).
Section 10: On the Relativity of the Conception of Distance. Man walking.
At first, in order to measure a length on the train, Einstein describes the correct approach. Then, he described an alternative approach which is incorrect. This amounts to, in effect, ‘timing’ the distance. Einstein does not go into detail in this Section, that is covered in his earlier papers. The alternative methodology for timing and measuring space is explained in Sections 4.5 and 4.6 using that material.
Not only are rods used to measure the distance in the first approach, but the reference is the train. The fact that it is moving is irrelevant, and that should be so, because the objective is to measure a distance on the train. Whereas, in the second method, the distance is measured with respect to the embankment, which is ‘stationary’ (ie with respect to the earth), whilst the train is moving with respect to the earth. Einstein is therefore trying to measure a distance on the train which is moving away from the point of reference, via sight. As has been explained many times, since there is a delay between creation of a representation and its receipt, then relative spatial position may vary. This is why the two methods of measuring difference can result in different outcomes.
Einstein’s assertion: A priori it is by no means certain that this last measurement will supply us with the same result as the first, is true, but that is because the first method was a valid way of measuring distance, while the second method was invalid, which is not what Einstein meant. As can be seen by his next statement: Thus the length of the train as measured from the embankment may be different from that obtained by measuring in the train itself. This circumstance leads us to a second objection which must be raised against the apparently obvious consideration of Section 6. Namely, if the man in the carriage covers the distance w in a unit of time, measured from the train, then this distance, as measured from the embankment is not necessarily also equal to w.
The actuality is that the distance on the train was a fixed length, it does not alter with differing ways of perceiving it through sensory systems. Similarly the man on the train moved at the speed of the train, plus the speed of his walking, with respect to the earth.
6.2.4 Section 7: The Apparent Incompatibility of the Law of Propagation of Light with the Principle of Relativity. Ray of light.
The actuality is that the speed of the ray of light with respect to the carriage will be c – v. The justification of using c, rather than the actual speed, is noted: We shall imagine the air above it to have been removed. The following statement is incorrect: The velocity W of the man relative to the embankment is here replaced by the velocity of light relative to the embankment. Einstein specified three sentences previously that: the tip of the ray will be transmitted with the velocity c relative to the embankment. The man was on a carriage that was moving at v with respect to the embankment. He then walked forward at w with respect to the carriage, which meant that overall his speed was v + w with respect to the embankment. The ray of light had no relationship with the carriage, and had been specified by Einstein as c with respect to the embankment anyway.
So, as Einstein states: The velocity of propagation of a ray of light relative to the carriage thus comes out smaller than c. That is, c – v. But, because of Einstein’s flawed understanding of the principle of relativity, he had a self-inflicted problem with that obvious outcome which accords with reality. This is encapsulated in: For, like every other general law of nature, the law of the transmission of light in vacuum must, according to the principle of relativity, be the same for the railway carriage as a reference-body, as when the rails are the body of reference. But, from our above consideration, this would appear to be impossible. This is the other principle which Einstein misconceived, since an entity cannot be the same speed with reference to two entities which are travelling at different velocities.
As noted above, the detail of light speed in a vacuum can be ignored. The point here is that there was one entity (a ray of light) which had an actual velocity with respect to the earth, which Einstein himself defined. Einstein resolved the apparent issue with his new methodology for timing, and measuring space. Which for this example made the speed of light the same with respect to the carriage and the embankment, contrary to reality.
6.2.5 Section 8: On the Idea of Time in Physics, Section 9: The Relativity of Simultaneity. Section 10: On the Relativity of the Conception of Distance. Strikes of lightening.
Lightening struck the embankment at two places simultaneously. So, yet again, despite the fact that this was a statement of the actuality, Einstein tried to develop a methodology to validate simultaneity, and thereby arrive at a different outcome. He rejected a sensible solution on the basis that: your definition would certainly be right, if only I knew that the light by means of which the observer at M perceives the lightning flashes travels along the length A to M with the same velocity as along the length B to M. But an examination of this supposition would only be possible if we already had at our disposal the means of measuring time. This was an acceptable rephrasing of the criterion for proof. Though it ignored the facts that the point M was equidistant from the two strikes at A and B, and the light from both these points was travelling at the same speed, ie there was nothing to prove in the first place.
Einstein then placed a timing device at three places, ie the locations of the lightening strikes (A & B), and the mid-point (M), assuring that they were of similar construction, would work in the same way, and that ‘telling the time’ involved watching the position of the pointers on them. But on this occasion, his flawed methodology of timing which he usually deployed to demonstrate that an alternative existed to the obvious solution, was irrelevant. Careful examination of what he actually said reveals that Einstein used another method.
Section 9 is concerned with Eistein’s attempt to define simultaneity. Poincaré asserted in 1902: There is no absolute time. When we say that two periods are equal, the statement has no meaning. We have no direct intuition of the simultaneity of two events occurring in two different places. A sentiment which Einstein followed. Einstein starts the Section: Up to now our considerations have been referred to a particular body of reference, a “railway embankment”. This is correct, since the example has been about two simultaneous lightening strikes on the embankment, and the possibility of placing an observer there.
However, Einstein alters the scenario: We suppose a very long train travelling along the rails with the constant velocity v. People travelling in this train regard all events in reference to the train. But originally there was no train, whether long or short, or whether moving or stationary. Then, in order to address Einstein’s irrelevant concerns about simultaneity, he suggested that an observer be at the midpoint on the train in order to prove simultaneity. A similar solution having already been rejected by him when he wanted proof that the light travelled at the same speed in both directions. Another irrelevant concern, since the light speed has been deemed to be constant by everybody, including Einstein.
The issue now was that there were two different reference points, train and embankment, and that the observers were on the train which was moving, whilst the lightening struck the embankment. Einstein: the definition of simultaneity can be given relative to the train in exactly the same way as with respect to the embankment. This is incorrect as there is a confusion of references. That is proven by Einstein’s next statement: are two events which are simultaneous with reference to the railway embankment, also simultaneous relatively to the train? We shall show that the answer must be in the negative.
The notion that the answer to the question posed might not be true, once any adjustment is made to allow for how that knowledge was obtained by observers, again starkly demonstrates the invalidity of the concept of Relativity. Einstein tried to extricate himself from this position by: When we say that the lightning strikes A and B are simultaneous with respect to be embankment, we mean: the rays of light emitted at the places A and B meet each other at the mid-point M of the length A to B of the embankment. But the events A and B also correspond to positions A and B on the train. This is incorrect, and not because originally the lightening struck the embankment and there was no train. It is incorrect because the only reference point was the embankment, which was stationary (in the sense that it was ‘of the earth’), whilst the train was moving with respect to the embankment.
Einstein then makes the most fundamental of mistakes: Let M’ be the mid-point of the distance A to B on the train. Just when the lightning occurs, M’ coincides with M, but it moves with the velocity v of the train. If an observer sitting in the position M′ in the train did not possess this velocity, then he would remain permanently at M, and the light rays emitted by the flashes of lightning A and B would reach him simultaneously, ie they would meet just where he is situated. [This is equivalent to the original proposition to prove simultaneity, except that the observer was to be on the embankment midway between the two stikes, as there was no train].
Now in reality, ie considered with reference to the railway embankment, he is hastening towards the beam of light coming from B, whilst he is riding on ahead of the beam of light coming from A. Hence the observer will see the beam of light emitted from B earlier than he will see that emitted from A. Observers who take the railway train as their reference-body must therefore come to the conclusion that the lightning flash B took place earlier than the lightning flash A. We thus arrive at the important result: Events which are simultaneous with reference to the embankment are not simultaneous with respect to the train, and vice versa (relativity of simultaneity).
Until this point, for the purposes of this example, the fact that Einstein had conflated a light- based representation of the event with the event itself, could have been ignored. Since, the observable light, though not c, was constant, distances were equidistant, and any movement was uniform rectilinear and non-rotary. Therefore, representation of actuality could be equivalenced with actuality.
If the recipent of the representations is moving towards one representation (light B), and hence away from the other (light A), then obviously the timings of the receipt are going to be different. Whether the observer comes to the conclusion, or not, that the lightning flash B took place earlier than the lightning flash A is irrelevant. Observation is not reality.
The difference was simply the function of an alteration in spatial position, with respect to the two lights, which occurred whilst the representations were travelling. A circumstance that was not included in the original definition of the example. It did not prove that: Events which are simultaneous with reference to the embankment are not simultaneous with respect to the train, and vice versa (relativity of simultaneity). What it did prove was that Einstein made a fundamental mistake with referencing. The presumption by Einstein that this could have been in any way correct can be traced back to his misinterpretation of Galileo’s ship analogy. This erroneous solution was used, either explicitly or implicitly, to ‘explain’ other previously described examples (eg stone dropping, man walking).
6.2.6 Section 10: On the Relativity of the Conception of Distance
Einstein attempts to explain how to measure space. In effect he ‘times’ it, which leads to the same flawed conclusion arrived at in the context of timing. For example: Thus the length of the train as measured from the embankment may be different from that obtained by measuring in the train itself.
6.2.7 Section 18: Special and General Principle of Relativity. In the train carriage
The flaw is in the caveat as long as it is moving uniformly. Einstein asserted that if the motion was such that the occupant could not feel it, then it is impossible to discern the relative motion. Although, all other sensory systems which could detect the movement would have to be ‘negated’ as well. The requirement of moving uniformly, in conjunction with other restrictions not explicitly stated, is yet another statement of the obvious which is meaningless, but presented as if it reveals a significant fact.
Einstein then stated that: according to the special principle of relativity, this interpretation is quite justified also from a physical point of view. But that is because, as explained previously, the special circumstances within which Relativity was supposed to prevail, were based on a misinterpretation of Galileo, not because they were inherently valid. The notion of how the carriage moved, etc, is the equivalent of Galileo’s smooth seas and no view out of the cabin. But the smooth seas were necessary so that the motion experiments would have the same outcome even though the ship was sailing, and not moored in the harbour. Galileo was proving that the earth could be moving since the motions were the same. That is, a notion that could be argued to demonstrate that the earth was not moving, was really a function of omnipresent pysical effects of being on the earth.
Einstein then introduced a different form of motion: a powerful application of the brakes, then the occupant of the carriage experiences a correspondingly powerful jerk forwards a powerful application of the brakes, then the occupant of the carriage experiences a correspondingly powerful jerk forwards. Given his flawed understanding, this is then considered by him in terms of referencing (usually K & K’, & S & S’), with the conclusion that certain laws no longer appear to hold: The mechanical behaviour is different from that of the case previously considered, and for this reason it would appear to be impossible that the same mechanical laws hold relatively to the non-uniformly moving carriage, as hold with reference to the carriage when at rest or in uniform motion. It is clear that the Galileian law does not hold with respect to the non-uniformly moving carriage.
The point being made is true, if it is understood that the circumstance involves sensory perception, and a misinterpretation of Galileo. On the basis of these errors, Einstein then had a problem: So, we feel compelled at present to grant a kind of absolute physical reality to non-uniform motion, in opposition to the general principle of relativity. That is, the underlying notion of the general circumstances cannot hold, given his interpretation. However, that is because the circumstance of his special version is invalid. The underlying notion of general relativity, in the context of sensory perception, is valid.
Einstein then needed to resolve this self-induced conundrum: But in what follows we shall soon see that this conclusion cannot be maintained. In Section 18 (General Relativity 1916) Einstein was striving for: In contrast to this we wish to understand by the “general principle of relativity” the following statement: All bodies of reference K, K′, etc., are equivalent for the description of natural phenomena (formulation of the general laws of nature), whatever may be their state of motion. Although he immediately explained that this version will be superseded by another: But before proceeding farther, it ought to be pointed out that this formulation must be replaced later by a more abstract one, for reasons which will become evident at a later stage.
The supposed proof that the conclusion reached at the end of that Section, ie we feel compelled at present to grant a kind of absolute physical reality to non-uniform motion, in opposition to the general principle of relativity, could be discounted, was given in Section 20. Section 19 introduced the gravitational field, with one ultimate objective being to prove an interdependence between Relativity and Gravitational Theory, which was invalid.
6.2.8 Section 20: The Equality of Inertial and Gravitational Mass as an Argument for the General Postulate of Relativity. Man in chest
This contains all the fallacies Einstein has previously used to substantiate his argument, and therefore will not be commented on again. The result of this dysfunctional logic is supposedly: We have thus good grounds for extending the principle of relativity to include bodies of reference which are accelerated with respect to each other, and as a result we have gained a powerful argument for a generalised postulate of relativity. Expressed another way: We can now appreciate why that argument is not convincing, which we brought forward against the general principle of relativity [above]. That is, it is certainly true that the observer in the railway carriage experiences a jerk forwards as a result of the application of the brake, and that he recognises, in this the non-uniformity of motion (retardation) of the carriage. But he is compelled by nobody to refer this jerk to a “real” acceleration (retardation) of the carriage. He might also interpret his experience thus: My body of reference (the carriage) remains permanently at rest. With reference to it, however, there exists (during the period of application of the brakes) a gravitational field which is directed forwards and which is variable with respect to time. Under the influence of this field, the embankment together with the earth moves non-uniformly in such a manner that their original velocity in the backwards direction is continuously reduced.
The actual argument Einstein proposed, as opposed to what he claimed it was, is as follows. Relativity was at all times concerned with the relativity of the receipt of representations of reality, not reality. These two existent states were conflated, both in the ‘special’ and ‘general’ circumstances. The special circumstance, within which Relativity was first described, was invalid. Since it involved ascribing a false equivalence to a certain mode of movement due to a misinterpretation of Galileo, a non-existent hypothetical state with no gravitational effect, and the invalid use of light speed in a vacuum, c, as the universal reference for movement. In order to invoke a general circumstance within which Relativity could be deemed to exist, albeit actually, as opposed to what Einstein thought, only in respect of the receipt of representations, Einstein had to discount the special circumstance on the basis of similar spurious arguments which had originally been used to justify it, while trying to claim that the original hypothesis still had some validity.
So, there was a man on a train who experienced braking, and hence, according to Einstein, but not really, this appeared to invalidate a general form of Relativity. However, it did not, according to Einstein, but not really, with the introduction of the experience of gravity, which has certain characteristics which mimic the misinterpretation of Galileo. Meanwhile, while all this variation in perception is happening, reality actually occurs in a definitive spatial position, at a definitive time. The nature of any given gravitational field, as with any given physically existent entity, is not a function of whatever it is referenced to. Whereas, the representation of any given reality by any given sensory system, in terms of time and space, is a function of spatial relationships.