3.2.1 Calculating movement: Configuration 1: Back and forth over fixed distance
Michelson (1881): The Relative Motion of the Earth and the Luminiferous Ether
Assuming the ether is at rest, the earth moving through it. Suppose the direction of a line joining the two points to coincide with the direction of earth’s motion. Then the time required for light to pass from one point to another on the earth’s surface, would depend on the direction in which it travels. Let:
V = velocity of light
v = speed of the earth with respect to the ether
D = distance between the two points
d = distance earth moves while light travels between points [away from each other]
d’ = distance earth moves while light travels between points [towards each other]
T = time for light to pass between points when travelling away from each other
T’= time for light to pass between points when travelling towards each other
To = time for light to pass between points when earth is at rest.
Then: T = (D + d)/V = d/v and T’ = (D – d’)/V = d’/v
Therefore: d = D[v/(V – v)] and d’ = D[v/(V + v)]
Therefore: T = D/(V – v) and T’ = D/(V + v). So: T + T’ = 2D[V/( V²– v²)]
If the light had travelled in a direction at right angles to the earth’s motion it would be entirely unaffected and the time of going and returning is 2To = 2D/V. Difference between T+T’ and 2To is 2DV[v²/(V²(V²– v²)]nearly or 2Tov²/ V² nearly. The distance light travels in the first case [T+T’] is greater than in the second [2To], by the quantity 2D(v²/V²).
Correct expressions are:
Total time when earth moving is: T+T’ = 2DV/(V²- v²)]
Total time when earth is stationary is: 2To = 2D/V
Difference between these is: 2Dv2/[V( V²- v²)]
On the same subject, Lorentz: If L is the distance of the points, V the velocity of light, and p that of earth, then: the time (if line of points parallel to direction of motion) is 2(L/V)(1 +p2/V2), and if it is perpendicular to it 2(L/V)(1 + p2/2V2). Making a difference of Lp2/V3. So the rays that travel forth and back in the earth’s direction suffer a delay of Lp2/V3 in respect to the other [perpendicular back and forth] ray.
Example:
Let V = 10, v = 2, D = 6
When the earth and the light are moving in the same direction:
T = 0.75, the earth travels 1.5, the light travels 7.5
When the earth and the light are moving towards each other:
T’ = 0.5, the earth travels 1, light travels 5
When the earth does not move:
To = 0.6, the light travels 6.
Total time is 1.25 when earth moves, and 1.2 when stationary.
Total distance the light travels is 12.5 when the earth moves, and 12 when stationary.
Total distance the earth moves is 2.5.
Most of Michelson’s expressions are correct, though the ones that are ‘nearly’ correct are of concern, since they should be correct, not an approximation. The first expression of Lorentz is nearly correct, the other two are incorrect.
Comment:
This is a truism, ie if two entities are related in this way, then that is the answer. The fact that one is light is irrelevant, since it is still a physically existent entity, as is the earth.
Superficially, the deemed stationary reference appears to be the ether, as the speed of the earth is stated by Michelson to be with respect to the ether. But the ether is said to be at rest, with the earth moving through it, which does not necessarily mean it is stationary. Neither is any specific movement of the ether, or spatial point within it, stipulated. The fixed distance is of the earth, ie its velocity is defined by the earth movement. Light speed is deemed to be ‘independent’, ie a constant. Irrespective of what was declared, the ether is irrelevant in the circumstance as defined.
In the first part, ie when the light and earth move in the same direction: v has a ‘headstart’ of D, as the defined circumstance is fulfilled when V catches up with what was the finish point of D, before it moved forwards. So, when does Vt = D + vt?
In the second part, ie when they move in opposite directions: the two entities need to meet. One is travelling from what was the start of D and the other from what was the finish point of D. So, when does Vt = D – vt?
Irrespective of the ‘mathematical’ issues, which might reflect typographical mistakes(?), the important point, as Michelson noted, is that the distance travelled by the light is different in the two parts of the movement, and the total of that is different from the total when earth is stationary. Hence, the durations incurred are different.
There tends to be an incorrect presumption associated with this configuration. That is, while the times incurred travelling either way are expected to be different from one another, the total time taken going back and forth will be the same, whether or not the fixed distance moves. This is because the velocities and fixed distance are unchanged, which gives rise to the notion that when the fixed distance is moving, the differences travelling one way, as opposed to the other, will compensate for each other, and therefore be equivalent to twice that incurred when the fixed distance is stationary.
‘Time’ has not altered, neither has the fixed distance, and the light has a constant speed. It is just that by moving the fixed distance with respect to the light, the distance the light needs to travel alters, and hence the duration incurred varies. The potential for reifying ‘time’, and distance, by using x = vt as a means of expressing distance was noted in Section 2.1.8. The confusion that can arise by referring a movement to something which has a known movement of its own, ie a derivative movement, as opposed to something which is ‘stationary’, ie the actual, was noted in Section 2.1.9. The derivation of √(1 – v2/V2) is explained in Section 3.2.2.
End of Comment
In respect of a possible way of detecting a motion of the solar system through the ether, Maxwell wrote to the American astronomer David Todd (Director of the Nautical Almanac Office) in 1879, and enquired about the observational accuracy of the moons of Jupiter. Maxwell stated: Even if we were sure of the theory of aberration, we can only get differences of position of stars, and in the terrestrial methods of determining the velocity of light, the light comes back along the same path again, so that the velocity of the earth with respect to the ether would alter the time of the double passage by a quantity depending on the square of the ratio of the earth’s velocity to that of light, and this is quite too small to be observed.
Both Lorentz and Michelson alluded to Maxwell. Lorentz 1892: It was noted by Maxwell that if the ether remains at rest, then the motion of earth must have an influence on the time required by light to travel forth and back between two points regarded as fixed to earth. Michelson 1881: The difference depending on the square of the ratio of the two velocities, according to Maxwell, is far too small to measure.
Concerns about the experiments include questions as to what type of earth movement was referenced, and why? Then to explain how that was known at any given spatial position at any given time? The underlying issue being whether if the light had travelled in a direction at right angles to the earth’s motion is the equivalent of the earth being ‘stationary’ with respect to the light? Which is what the time of going and returning is 2D/V = 2To actually means. Lorentz referred to the perpendicular.
As hypothetical depictions of light movement these may suffice, especially since there are other serious concerns with these experiments anyway. The author assumes that by now there is a reasonable understanding of the variations involved in the relevant two, of the four, earth movements, ie its rotation on its axis, and its elliptical orbit round the sun. As well as the effect of refraction on light velocity as it passes through layers of the earth’s atmosphere. Hence, in the time taken for any given light from the sun to reach the earth, the spatial difference between where it would have been received had there not been a delay, and where it actually was, in respect of any given location at any given time, is understood. Should that be necessary to establish.
Then, leaving aside earth-bound sources of light, there is reflected light. Because it involves the same atomic process, the start speed of reflected light is the same as incident light, ie it is not affected by the velocity of any given entity involved, or that of the light previously. This was one of Lorentz’s key conclusions. After that, its velocity depends on the physical circumstances encountered during transmission, which, given the nature of light as a physically existent entity, are minimal. Therefore, on earth, given the distances involved and the homogeneity of the medium through which light travels, for practical purposes it can be assumed that invariably light travels at a constant speed in a straight line. But that speed is not c. Something moving towards the direction of travel of any given light must receive it before what would have been the case had it been moving away from, or stationary to, that light. That is, while the speed is actually constant, the outcome when compared to different movements is not.
In other words, there is no necessity for experiments, or discussions, in order to establish this as a generality. Furthermore, using light, per se, in an attempt to discern earth movement is pointless. As too would be using the ‘ether’, whatever that is. Neither provide an acceptable reference against which to establish movement in our existentially closed system, as explained in Section 2.1. Understanding the nature of light is essential, so that when received, when and where the occurrence happened, as depicted in a light-based representation, can be determined.
In conclusion, there is serious concern as to whether a mirror contraption attached to a stone base floating in mercury could have proved anything. Possibly, with current technology, such vanishingly small variations can be detected. But the general outcome was known anyway, so the exercise was not necessary, ie these experiments, and their results, were best ignored. But this is not what happened.
3.2.2 Calculating movement: Configuration 2: General
The above sub-section addressed a particular circumstance. This section addresses that relationship between two entities in general. Distance is the spatial difference between any given pair of physically existent states at any given time. It is a spatial quantity reflecting a unique occurrence in terms of when, and what was involved. For there to be a distance whatever is under consideration must exist at the same time, since something that is non-existent cannot have a spatial position. As distance is a difference, it does not physically exist, only the states do in their respective spatial positions at that time.
Distance can only be expressed properly in terms of spatial units, by comparing spatial positions and identifying the difference. However, it can be expressed in terms of duration, ie x = vt. This is hypothetical, as it is the duration which would have been incurred had any given entity, at a known velocity, been able to travel that difference in either direction. But any given distance is only manifest once, so misinterpretation of this method of expression can result in the reification of distance.
Movement is alteration in distance, revealed when discrete distances in sequences are compared retrospectively. As calculating movement, as opposed to distance, involves sequence, any given entity/representation involved has to be deemed to be the ‘same’ thing over the duration of the measurement. Comparison of these discrete distances enables the calculation of velocity, which involves speed, ie rate of alteration in distance, and divergence, ie rate of alteration in direction.
For movement the reference needs to be something which is constantly ‘stationary’. But everything is moving. However, as we are in a closed system and the options are finite, whatever is designated the reference against which everything else is compared is, in effect, ‘stationary’. Calculating movement with respect to a proper reference reveals the actual movement, whereas, measurements made with respect to something which has a known difference in velocity vis a vis that reference, ie a movement of its own, reveals a derivative movement. The comparison of different movements involves √(1 – v2/V2), where V is the faster moving entity.
Let it be assumed that both entities start from the same point at the same time, travel at a constant speed, and do so along the same line of dimension. Their distance apart on any occasion is denoted as x. When travelling in the same direction, the distance between them per t is V-v. When travelling in opposite directions, the distance between them per t is V+v. In all other circumstances, their direction of travel is diverging, either at an acute, obtuse, or right, angle. Whilst the two entities maintain a constant velocity, the change in relative spatial position remains constant. They are in a fixed spatial relationship with each other, ie the actual value of x varies at each t, but the rate at which it does so remains constant.
For the sake of illustration, let the entities start from the same point on the x axis, at the same time, and be deemed to finish whenever they reach a y axis at the same time. If this arrangement is represented as a right-angled triangle, then while the slower moving entity (v) travels along the x axis, the faster moving entity (V) travels along the hypotenuse. The difference between them on any occasion is manifested by the two finish points on the y axis. In Pythagorean terms: h2 = y2 + x2. As v increases whilst V remains constant, then the angle of incline of the hypotenuse decreases, and x decreases. As V increases while v remains constant, then the angle of incline of the hypotenuse increases, and x increases.
When the circumstance is not designed to be representable by a right-angled triangle, but requires the two finish points be related vertically which determines their degree of divergence, the law of cosines applies. When the angle of divergence is obtuse, any increase in that angle, and/or any increase in either, or both, of the velocities, results in an increase in x, and vice versa. When the angle of divergence is acute, a variance in velocity can alter x either way, depending on the velocities.
Alternatively, the above relationship can be demonstrated as follows. Instead of referencing both constant movements to a common start point, let the slower moving entity travel along the x axis, with reference to the original start point, whilst the movement upwards of the faster moving entity is referenced to the slower moving entity. So, on each occasion, the faster moving entity travels V from its start point. But instead of travelling vertically, its directional path is determined by the intersection of that, and its distance from the slower moving entity on the x axis, on each occasion. The direction of travel of the faster moving entity, and hence the degree of divergence of the two entities, depends on the ratio V:v.
Yet another way of representing this relationship is to constrict it in terms of duration and spatial position. That is, the two entities must start at the same position, at the same time, and finish at the same position, which is different from the start, at the same time. Both movements are referenced to the same start point. So, whilst the slower moving entity travels along the x axis to the finish point, the faster moving entity must travel an extra distance to arrive at that point, in the same duration, ie it incurs a certain amount of ‘lateral displacement’, a distance V – v per t. As it is travelling at a constant velocity, the path of this displacement can be represented by a triangle with a base on the x axis of vt, and two sides equal to ½Vt. If both entities had to follow a path along the x axis, then in order to satisfy the same circumstances, the slower moving entity would have to be given a ‘head start’ of V – v per t.
The effect of relating V and v can be expressed as the ratio ‘V with v’: ‘V without v’. With v, x = t√(V2 – v2), or as a hypothetical duration, x/√(V2 – v2). Without v, x = Vt, or expressing that distance as a hypothetical duration, x/V.
The ratios of with/without v are:
Distance, (with v)/(without v) is: t√(V2 – v2)/Vt = √(V2 – v2)/V or √(1 – v2/V2)
or (without v)/(with v) is: V/√(V2 – v2) or 1/√(1 – v2/V2)
Duration, (with v)/(without v) is: [X/√(V2 – v2)]/X/V = V/√(V2 – v2) or 1/√(1 – v2/V2)
or (without v)/(with v) is: √(V2 – v2)/V or √(1 – v2/V2)
3.2.3 Calculating movement: Configuration 3: Receipt of representation
The above sub-sections concerned the relationship between entities in terms of occurrence, ie the fact that one of them could be light was irrelevant, as it is a physically existent entity in itself. The relationship being considered here involves the receipt of a representation of one of the entities, rather than the entity itself. The diagrammatical difference being that each measurement is taken when the representation intersects (is received) with the other entity, ie distance, and hence movement, is being deduced from the receipt of representations by the other entity.
The time of occurrence, and spatial position at that time, can only be determined from when, and where, the representations were received. However, as different entities cannot occupy the same spatial position there is always a distance between them, which means there is always a delay between occurrence and the representation being created, and when it was received. Hence, the distance travelled, and the duration thereby incurred, is a function of the spatial position of the occurrence with respect to the position of what became the ‘receiving’ entity when the representation was received. Not the distance between the event and that entity when it happened, or when the representation was received. Therefore, alterations in spatial position whilst any representation is travelling are critical.
The movement of the ‘emitting’ entity is deduced from the receipt of representations of it by the other entity. While an event occurred at a specific time, due to differing spatial positions, when the representation of it was received by various entities will likely vary. This could involve the original differences in spatial position, with respect to the occurrence, remaining the same, or, during the delay there is some alteration in that spatial position.
The circumstance becomes more complicated when it involves a sequence of occurrences. In a relationship involving a representation, then the path of a representation, at any given t, would be defined by a distance starting from a point on the path of the ‘emitting’ entity at that t (which is also the start of the distance (x) between the entities at that t), to a point on the path of the ‘receiving’ entity, which would be beyond the end point of distance x. The relationship between ‘distance x’ and ‘distance transmission’, at any given t, again involves the factor √(1 – v2/V2).
Assuming a regularity in the sequence, and a constancy of velocity in the ‘emitting’, and ‘receiving’, entities, then the frequency of the sequence, when calculated with respect to the entity receiving the representations, will be constant. However, if the relationship of distance and/or direction varies from occasion to occasion, then their relative spatial position could vary on each such occasion, and the frequency appear to vary from that emitted to that received.
This is because, as the spatial relationship alters, then successive representations have to travel distances which alter at a varying rate. Then, a sequence calculated with respect to the ‘receiving’ entity, either increases or decreases at a rate dependent upon the rate at which relative spatial position is altering whilst the representation is being transmitted. That is, it appears, to the ‘receiving’ entity, to be speeding up, or slowing down, though the actual emitted rate did not change. This is the Doppler effect, which if not understood, can result in the belief that ‘time’ is altering.