Hall of Mirrors: Section 3.4: Poincaré

3.4.1 What Poincaré wrote
After pages of argument Poincaré states the following conclusions:

1. There is no absolute space, and we only conceive of relative motion.

2. There is no absolute time. When we say that two periods are equal, the statement has no meaning. We have no direct intuition of the simultaneity of two events occurring in two different places.

These statements are invalid, as explained in Section 2.1.

3.4.2 What Poincaré wrote
He then went on to assert that:
The principle of relativity [of motion], according to which the laws of physical phenomena must be the same for a stationary observer as for an observer carried along in a uniform motion of translation; so that we have not, and cannot have, any means of discerning whether or not we are carried along in such a motion.

 
This misinterpreted Galileo, and resulted in a false equivalence of a certain mode of motion. Also, as there is no physical relationship between reality and any given reference, the laws of physical phenomena cannot be affected by, or have an effect on, what actually happened. Physical existence has already occurred when its manifestation is received.

The principle of relativity of motion, as expressed by Poincaré, and subsequently Einstein, is an invalid concept. The laws of physical phenomena must be valid statements based on proven direct experience, or logical deduction therefrom, about actual physical events. Not as defined with respect to some arbitrary reference. These occur irrespective of whether they are sensed or not, or the state of motion of the entity receiving representations of them. That is, it is irrelevant what sensory system is involved, or whether the recipient entity is human/non-human, stationary/moving, in respect of what actually occurred.

The point Galileo made in 1632, when he described a thought experiment involving a ship, was to counter ideas that the earth was stationary. An argument for that being if the earth was moving, then objects would fall differently according to circumstances. Galileo imagined being in a ship’s cabin observing a variety of simple motions whilst the ship was ‘stationary’, as in with respect to the earth. He then suggested that if these motions were repeated with the ship moving at a uniform speed, the effects would be the same. The purpose of this was to demonstrate that if the earth is moving that would not necessarily be noticed, unless some other clue was available, as the motion of the earth is common to all things associated with it, which can give the false impression that it is stationary.

Observation was invoked for obvious reasons, and not because that had some different generic characteristic compared to all other sensory systems. Similarly, the proposed alternative motion to being ‘stationary’ (eg in the harbour) was a uniform translation (eg calm seas), because otherwise it would be known that the ship was moving. But more importantly, the experiments could be affected. That is, what sensory system was used was irrelevant, ie this was not about some characteristic of light, and the choice of alternative motion to ‘stationary’ was purely so that the experiments were not affected by that very movement, ie this was not concerned with ‘inertial frames of reference’.

Einstein’s version of Galileo’s ship analogy was: The pillar upon which the “theory of relativity” rests is the so-called principle of relativity: Picture two physicists. Let both be equipped with every physical instrument imaginable, and have a laboratory. Suppose the laboratory of one of the physicists is arranged somewhere in an open field, and that of the second in a railroad car traveling at constant velocity in a given direction. The principle of relativity states the following: if, using all their equipment, these two physicists were to study all the laws of nature, one in his stationary laboratory and the other in his laboratory on the train, they would discover exactly the same laws of nature, provided that the train is not shaking and is travelling in uniform motion. We can say: according to the principle of relativity, the laws of nature are independent of the translational motion of the reference system, and are identical in all acceleration-free systems.

 
The fact that Einstein has misunderstood the point Galileo was making, and how proper referencing is applied, is demonstrated by: provided that the train is not shaking and is travelling in uniform motion. Both Poincaré and Einstein thought that sensing had an effect on what they regarded as the actuality, and that this was negated so long as the reference was in a certain mode of motion. Both notions are invalid. This falsehood was repeated in General Relativity (1916) with two examples, a man on a train, and a man in a chest.

3.4.3 What Poincaré wrote
The most ingenious idea was that of local time. Imagine two observers who wish to adjust their timepieces by optical signals. When station B perceives the signal from station A, its clock should not mark the same hour as that of station A at the moment of sending the signal, but this hour augmented by a constant representing the duration of the transmission. Suppose, for example, that station A sends its signal when its clock marks the hour 0, and that station B perceives it when its clock marks the hour t. The clocks are adjusted if the slowness equal to t represents the duration of the transmission, and to verify it, station B sends in its turn a signal when its clock marks 0; then station A should perceive it when its clock marks t. The timepieces are then adjusted.

 
They mark the same hour at the same physical instant, but on the one condition, that the two stations are fixed. Otherwise the duration of the transmission will not be the same in the two senses, since the station A, for example, moves forward to meet the optical perturbation emanating from B, whereas the station B flees before the perturbation emanating from A. The watches adjusted in that way will not mark, therefore, the true time; they will mark what may be called the local time, so that one of them will be slow of the other. It matters little, since we have no means of perceiving it. All the phenomena which happen at A, for example, will be late, but all will be equally so, and the observer will not perceive it, since his watch is slow; so, as the principle of relativity requires, he will have no means of knowing whether he is at rest or in absolute motion.

 
This is invalid, because it involves de-synchronisation of timing devices. See Section 4.5. Einstein repeated this methodology in Part 1, paras 1 & 2 in 1905. His conclusion being: So we see that we cannot attach any absolute signification to the concept of simultaneity, but that two events which, viewed from a system of co-ordinates, are simultaneous, can no longer be looked upon as simultaneous events when envisaged from a system which is in motion relatively to that system. This error is similar to the above. On this occasion, the improper use of referencing has resulted in reality being ‘altered’ in respect of when the events occurred, which was actually at the same time.

Neither does it represent Lorentz’s concept of local time anyway, as explained in Section 3.3. His supposed contraction in shape meant that, for the duration of the effect, the spatial position occupied, and its time of occurrence, was different from what would have otherwise happened. Lorentz: The variable t’ can be regarded as a time, counting from an instant that depends on the location of the point. We can therefore call this variable the local time of this point, in contrast to the general time t. The transition from one time to another is provided by equation t’ = t – (px/V2)x – (py/V2)y – (pz/V2)z. [Where p = translational velocity of ponderable matter, and V = velocity of light in the ether].

 
Finally, in 1905, Poincaré wrote: An explanation was proposed by Lorentz and FitzGerald, who introduced the hypothesis of a contraction by all bodies in the direction of the motion of earth, proportional to the square of aberration; this would give an account of the experiment of Michelson and all those which were carried out up to now. The hypothesis would become insufficient, however, if one were to assume the postulate of relativity in all its generality.

 
If one wants to preserve Lorentz’s theory, it is necessary to suppose a special force which explains at the same time the contraction, and the constancy of two of the axes. I sought to determine this force, I found that it can be compared to a constant external pressure, acting on the deformable and compressible electron, and whose work is proportional to the variations of the volume of the electron.

 
Having criticised Lorentz for deploying an additional hypothesis when some new feature arose, Poincaré did just that. In doing so, he demonstrated that he considered Lorentz’s explanation, ie contraction, of the (non-existent) issue with the Michelson experiments to be fundamentally correct, but just in need of some further refinement.

Scroll to Top