3.5.1 Einstein quotes.
The importance of Lorentz in Einstein’s own words, is:
The development [of the Special Theory of Relativity] starts off from the ideas of Faraday and Maxwell, according to which all physical processes involve a continuity of action, or, in the language of mathematics, they are expressed by partial differential equations. Maxwell succeeded in doing this for electro-magnetic processes in bodies at rest. The extension of electro-dynamics to the case of moving bodies fell to the lot of Maxwell’s successors.
From Fizeau’s experiment one had to conclude that the ether is not carried along completely by matter in motion, but instead there occurs a relative displacement. The earth being a body that rotates around its axis, and revolves around the sun, with velocities that change their directions, one should expect a spatial anisotropy in optical phenomena. Thus, in vacuum or in the atmosphere, light should propagate faster in the direction of the earth’s motion than in the opposite direction.
Experimental verification of this consequence was unthinkable, because the order of magnitude of the term considered is that of the ratio of the velocity of the earth to the velocity of light. Also, and this is a most important point, all terrestrial methods for measuring the velocity of light employ light rays that travel along a closed (back and forth) rather than a simple path, due to the fact that the times of departure and arrival of the rays must be determined with the help of one and the same device.
At this point, Lorentz came to the rescue. He achieved this by taking from ether its mechanical, and from matter its electromagnetic qualities. As in empty space, so too in the interior of material bodies, the ether was exclusively the seat of electromagnetic fields. Assuming that ether is completely immobile, Lorentz conceived a theory of electromagnetic phenomena. The special theory of relativity does not compel us to deny ether. We may assume [its] existence; only we must give up ascribing a definite state of motion to it.
The [Lorentz] theory appeared to be unsatisfactory only in one point. It appeared to give preference to one system of coordinates of a particular state of motion (at rest relative to the ether) as against all other systems of co-ordinates in motion with respect to this one. In this point the theory seemed to stand in direct opposition to classical mechanics, in which all inertial systems which are in uniform motion with respect to each other are equally justifiable as systems of co-ordinates. The Special Theory of Relativity owes its origin to this difficulty.
Lorentz and FitzGerald resorted to a strange hypothesis: they assumed that each body in motion, with respect to the ether, contracts in the direction of motion by a fraction equal to ½(v/c)2, or, which amounts to the same if only terms of second order are considered, that the length of the body is diminished in that direction in the ratio: 1 to Ö(1-v2/c2). This hypothesis supplies us then with that particular law of motion.
The [Special] theory of relativity leads to the same law of motion, without requiring any special hypothesis whatsoever as to the structure and the behaviour of the electron. It turned out that a sufficiently sharpened conception of time was all that was needed to overcome the difficulty. One had to realize that an auxiliary quantity, “local time”, could be defined as “time” in general. If one adheres to this definition of time, the basic equations of Lorentz’s theory correspond to the principle of relativity, provided that the [Galilean] transformation equations are replaced by ones that correspond to this new conception of time.
On the basis of the [Special] theory of relativity the method of interpretation is more satisfactory. There is no such thing as a “specially favoured” co-ordinate system. Here the contraction of moving bodies follows from the two fundamental principles of the theory, without the introduction of particular hypotheses; and as the prime factor involved in this contraction we find, not the motion in itself, to which we cannot attach any meaning, but the motion with respect to the body of reference chosen in the particular case in point.
3.5.2 Comment
In respect of the first paragraph, the author raises the issue of what constitutes movement, as everything is moving? Earth movements are varied, and considerable, but the underlying ones are omnipresent. So, a differentiation between what is ‘at rest’, and what is ‘moving’ and how, can be misconceived. Only a proper system of referencing can identify what is actually happening. See Section 2.1.
Misinterpretation of Galileo, see Section 3.4.2, lead to the presumption that, so long as something was in the mode of uniform translational motion irrespective of velocity, then when something else, with a constant movement, was referenced to it, the outcome must always be that constant. For this notion to be true, everything involved would have to be in a fixed spatial relationship, not just uniform translational motion. In which case the idea is meaningless. This resulted in the false notion of inertial frames of reference.
When contrasting Lorentz’s hypothesis with classical mechanics, this misinterpretation becomes apparent: In this point the theory seemed to stand in direct opposition to classical mechanics, in which all inertial systems which are in uniform motion with respect to each other are equally justifiable as systems of co-ordinates. The Special Theory of Relativity owes its origin to this difficulty. This depiction of classical mechanics is incorrect, and the Special Theory of Relativity involves the fundamental flaw based on the misinterpretation of Galileo.
What became known as The Special Theory of Relativity was contained in the first part, the Kinematical Part, of the 1905 paper entitled: On the electrodynamics of moving bodies. According to Einstein this hypothesis: is based on the kinematics of the rigid body, since the assertions of any such theory have to do with the relationships between rigid bodies (systems of co-ordinates), clocks, and electromagnetic processes. Insufficient consideration of this circumstance lies at the root of the difficulties which the electrodynamics of moving bodies at present encounters. The issue with this being that there is no physical relationship between the electrodynamics of bodies (rigid or otherwise) and clocks, ie time, and systems of co-ordinates, ie space. The author assumes that after over 100 years, the actual effect of any given motion on any given ‘body’, in respect of electrodynamics, etc, is understood.
Although it only becomes clear in later papers, what became known as Relativity in special circumstances was an alternative explanation to Lorentz. This [Lorentz] hypothesis supplies us then with that particular law of motion [length of the body is diminished in that direction in the ratio: 1 to Ö(1-v2/c2)]. The [Special] theory of relativity leads to the same law of motion, without requiring any special hypothesis whatsoever as to the structure and the behaviour of the electron. It turned out that a sufficiently sharpened conception of time was all that was needed to overcome the difficulty. One had to realize that an auxiliary quantity, “local time”, could be defined as “time” in general. And: Here the contraction of moving bodies follows from the two fundamental principles of the theory, without the introduction of particular hypotheses; and as the prime factor involved in this contraction we find, not the motion in itself, to which we cannot attach any meaning, but the motion with respect to the body of reference chosen in the particular case in point.
Lorentz’s hypothesis of contraction attempted to explain the apparent failure of Michelson’s experiments, which needed no explanation since those experiments were never going to manifest the outcomes that were expected, though the underlying notion was correct. Hence, there was no necessity to find some previously unknown factor.
For Lorentz, the contraction, albeit limited to one dimension and a particular direction, was not the function of referencing, but real: the motion of a rigid body, eg, a brass rod or the stone plate used in later experiments, would have an influence on the dimensions which, depending on the orientation of the body with respect to the direction of motion, is different, and thus cause a contraction in the direction of motion in the ratio of 1 to Ö(1 – p²/v²). Or: A change in length of the arms in the first experiment, and the stone plate in the second, is not inconceivable. Or: The displacement would cause a contraction in the direction of motion in the ratio of 1 to √(1-p²/V²).
Whilst it was implicit, Lorentz’s hypothesis presumed the existence of a force which was responsible for the variation in movement. In Einstein’s alternative hypothesis no such force was presumed, and the ‘contraction’ was not real, but explainable by other means: not the motion in itself, to which we cannot attach any meaning, but the motion with respect to the body of reference chosen in the particular case in point. Yet again, what was thought to be reality, was deemed alterable with referencing. Any given motion can be described with respect to any given reference, but that is pointless, as it mostly does not define the actual.
As previously stated, there could be a force and a consequent alteration in shape, though not as an explanation for the discrepancy between expected outcome and experimental results. In comparing velocities, and different processes, both of them employed the same mathematics, ie use of the factor √(1 – v2/V2), as explained in Section 3.2.1.
Comparing his solution with Lorentz’s, Einstein thought: The method of interpretation is more satisfactory. Here the contraction of moving bodies follows from the two fundamental principles of the theory [Special] without the introduction of particular hypotheses; and as the prime factor involved in this contraction we find, not the motion in itself, to which we cannot attach any meaning, but the motion with respect to the body of reference chosen in the particular case in point.
There are four key phrases in the above quotes: First, with respect to the ether. Second: [Lorentz] assuming that ether is completely immobile. Third: one had only to realize that an auxiliary quantity introduced by Lorentz, “local time”, could be defined as “time” in general. Fourth: without the introduction of particular hypotheses.
1 With respect to the ether
As explained in Sections 3.1 and 3.3, even when Lorentz did refer to ‘with respect to the ether’, the mathematics did not reflect that, neither was the ether relevant to his argument. Subsequently, Lorentz explicitly stated that the reference was: Instead of the co-ordinate system used above [coordinate system that is at rest in the ether], we introduce another one which is rigidly connected with ponderable matter and therefore shares any displacement. By a fixed point, we now understand one point that has a steady position with respect to the new axis. From now on it will be assumed that the bodies are moving at a steady velocity of translation p, under which we will have to understand in almost all applications, the speed of the Earth in its motion around the sun. Real velocity is thus: the velocity of the previously mentioned relative motion plus p.
2 Ether is immobile
Einstein falsely attributed how Lorentz involved the ether, both in respect of its use as a reference, see above, and its immobility. Lorentz: That we cannot speak about an absolute rest of the ether is self-evident. When I say the ether is at rest, this only means that one part of this medium does not move against the other.
Einstein’s concern with the ether was its potential, according to him, to provide a reference which would contravene his own thinking, which is characterised by: There is no such thing as a “specially favoured” co-ordinate system. The corollary being: ‘everything is relative’.
Is it really impossible to reconcile the essential foundations of Lorentz’s theory with the principle of relativity? If we wish to attempt such a reconciliation, the first step we must take is to give up the ether. For, on the one hand, we have been obliged to admit that the ether is stationary, whereas, on the other hand, the principle of relativity demands that the laws of natural phenomena referred to a uniformly moving coordinate system S’, be identical with the laws of these same phenomena referred to a system S, at rest with respect to the ether. But there is no reason to assume the immobility of ether any more with respect to the system S’, than with respect to the system S; these two systems cannot be distinguished from each other, and it is therefore improper to make one of them play a special role by saying that it is at rest with respect to the ether. It follows that the only way to arrive at a satisfactory theory is to give up the notion of a medium filling all of space.
Leaving aside the fact that there had been no obligation to admit that the ether is stationary, see above, the argument that followed was false anyway. The principle of relativity does not demand that the laws of natural phenomena referred to a uniformly moving coordinate system S’, be identical with the laws of these same phenomena referred to a system S, at rest with respect to the ether. Or another way of expressing that is that this interpretation of a principle of relativity is invalid. This is the consequence of the Galileo misinterpretation.
Furthermore, it is irrelevant what the motion of the ether is, because while the motion of S and S’ can be depicted in many different forms depending upon which reference is used, that proves nothing. What needs to be known is their actual motion in reality, using a referencing system which accords with the nature of our closed system. Finally, giving up the notion of a medium filling all of space is not the way to arrive at a satisfactory theory, but the way to fulfil Einstein’s flawed ideas. Giving up the ether does not lead to a theory, satisfactory or otherwise. Ether was given up because it was irrelevant to the circumstance being considered, ie light and bodies in states of motion.
Further, it is easy to see that we must also abandon the idea of introducing a luminiferous ether into the theory. Because, if every light ray in vacuum is supposed to propagate with the velocity c, with respect to K, then we must conceive of this luminiferous ether as being everywhere at rest with respect to K. However, if the laws of propagation of light with respect to the system K’ (in motion relative to K), are the same as those with respect to K, then we would have to assume, with as much right, the existence of a luminiferous ether that is at rest with respect to K’. Since it is absurd to assume that the luminiferous ether is simultaneously at rest with respect to both systems, and since it would be hardly less absurd for the theory to privilege one of the two (or of infinitely many) physically equivalent systems over the others, one must dispense with that concept, which was, anyway, just a useless accessory of the theory ever since the mechanical interpretation of light had been abandoned.
This is another false argument, involving one amongst several characteristics that Einstein incorrectly attributed to Lorentz, which he then used to justify his alternative hypothesis. What Lorentz said about light is misrepresented, which was that it always started, not continued, at c, and that the previous movement of that light, and what it reacted with, were irrelevant. Moreover, the transmitted speed could not be c, as the bodies were not in a vacuum. Then there is a repeat of the flawed argument with k, based on the Galileo misinterpretation, by which Einstein attempts to justify ‘giving up the ether’.
Einstein claimed: It may be added that the whole change in the conception of the ether which the special theory of relativity brought about, consisted in taking away from the ether its last mechanical quality, namely, its immobility. This is incorrect. For both Lorentz and Einstein, given what was being considered, the ether was irrelevant. Einstein admitted this: the special theory of relativity does not compel us to deny ether. We may assume the existence of an ether; only we must give up ascribing a definite state of motion to it.
3 ‘local time’ could be defined as ‘time’ in general
As explained Section 3.3.2, the statement: one had only to realize that an auxiliary quantity introduced by Lorentz, “local time”, could be defined as “time” in general, is incorrect. Lorentz’s concept of local time (and local spatial position) was valid, given his view that under certain conditions the shape of bodies altered, and therefore the time and position of any such affected entity would be different from what it would otherwise have been.
As stated in Section 3.4.3, Poincaré gave an example on how to synchronise timing devices based on his perspective that: There is no absolute time. When we say that two periods are equal, the statement has no meaning, and can only acquire a meaning by a convention. This methodology actually de-synchronised them. Einstein used this in Part 1 of the 1905 paper to justify the supposed relativity of time and space. See Sections 4.5 and 4.6.
4 Without the introduction of particular hypotheses
Here the contraction of moving bodies follows from the two fundamental principles of the theory, without the introduction of particular hypotheses; and as the prime factor involved in this contraction we find, not the motion in itself, to which we cannot attach any meaning, but the motion with respect to the body of reference chosen in the particular case in point.
Einstein implies that his alternative explanation, Relativity in special circumstances, must be correct as it does not involve the introduction of particular hypotheses. This is untrue, as it involved the misinterpretation of two fundamental principles, which led to the abandonment of a third valid principle, the invalid use of c as a universal reference point and instead of an ‘atmospheric’ speed of light, introduction of an incorrect methodology for calibrating time, space, and motion, and no gravitational effect. That is, Part 1 1905, implied an entirely new construct of physical existence, as noted by Minkowski.