This paper is concerned with Einstein’s concept of Relativity, and how it is invalid. It does not examine any repercussions which might arise from this.
For physics to be a science based on knowledge, rather than belief, and provide a coherent explanation (aka the Theory of Everything), it must be in accord with the inherent nature of the physical existence of which we are a part. The key point being that we are confined to an existentially closed system, as we cannot transcend our own existence, and can only know what it is possible for us to know from within it.
Given a closed system, the pursuit of due scientific process within it does not entail presumptions, if they are consistent with that system. Indeed, such an approach is a necessity. Not imposing such limitations, let alone using invalid ones, while superficially appearing a more intellectual form of analysis, will, other than by fortuitous coincidence, result in a construct of belief, not knowledge.
Furthermore, what physically exists can only be known to us through representations of it. While the physical processes involved in that need to be understood, physics is not a science of representations of what happened, but knowledge explaining what actually occurred. Reality, and representations thereof, must not be conflated. Neither should concepts such as space, x, y, z, and at a time, t, be reified and attributed with an independence disconnected from reality.
While the initial argument is expressed in generic terms and may appear simplistic, it actually enables exposure of fundamental facts about our physical existence. It could be referred to, colloquially, as a case of ‘seeing the wood by ignoring the trees’.
In the critique, the normal approach of references has not been followed. Since the author found that the writers explained themselves adequately, so there was no need to re-phrase them with the support of a complex system of referencing, which would lose the immediacy of what was written. More importantly, the author found that many derivative descriptions bore little relationship to what had actually been written a 100 years ago. Hence, quotes are given at the start of sections, and then selections therefrom used within the commentary in order to, in effect, give the original writers their ‘voice’ back. Unless otherwise stated, quotes in italics are Einstein.
In many cases whether what was actually said was correct, or not, either on the basis of what was known then, or known now, is irrelevant. Since a central issue is what was actually written at the time, and then how that was developed.
Paul